I made an open-source Desk Buddy/PC Monitor for ESP32-S3
Another AI companion in a long line of AI companions made by AI for AI.
Ah yes, out of all the apps on the device, there are 2 for ai(codex and claude code usage) and it’s suddenly an ai companion. But fuck the time I spent making artwork for this crab, or designing a 3d model case for the board I guess
It’s funny how people that “build” everything with AI are so weird about disclosing it/being called out on it.
Then attaching a trademark and license to the AI generated code that doesn’t allow changing the code that is originally stolen from actual open source projects that I’m sure also had trademarks and licenses.
I looked through the code a bit, it’s a mess. No educational value at all. It’s just another AI companion made by AI.
Doesn’t mean it doesn’t have any value to you, but for me it’s kinda sad that another space, the tinkerer space, is also being taken over by AI slop.
Mate, I’m sad when I code with AI for my projects because I would have loved to know everything, but without it I wouldn’t be able to do all these things, I’m trying at least to learn as much as I can by reading the code and actually asking about it. But there is no way I would have been able to make the code for these robots all alone, they have thousands of lines in the code! I still put effort in it! I’ve started electronics with 0 knowledge and had to learn from youtube,Ai,reddit etc.
And let’s be honest AI isn’t going anywhere, the box has been opened.
you’re not wrong about disclosure, but saying someone’s personal project that they aren’t charging for has “no educational value” is weird. they clearly just wanted a thing that does the job, and they chose to use AI to get there. we can all have thoughts about that but being mad at someone’s project for not fulfilling your personal requirements makes no sense.
normally i’m on board with the idea that AI is a thief, but if a project is open-source and someone uses that code for another open-source project, why would that matter? preventing other AIs from using the code is weird, yeah, but like what is the net loss here other than your perception of the tinkerer space?
i do think AI-generated code should be labeled as such, to warn people who can’t read the code and see that it’s a mess. mostly for security reasons. and of course if you’re charging, AI slop is unacceptable
Projects get forked all the time, that’s not the point. The point is that people like this boast “creating” something when they flashed a board with a code block they copy and pasted then 3d printed a case from makerworld lol. This person did not create anything. This project can’t really be forked by anyone real, for anything useful because the AI code is a rat king.
Usually people would share open source projects for 2 reasons.
It’s something hard to make/code on your own
It is unique and useful/there is educational value in building it yourself.
This item checks neither of those boxes. Pointing out that there was no value to anyone doing it themselves was warranted. A huge part of the arduino community is here for some part of education.
Its annoying, how I make a product for myself, take my time to share it and get attacked by people like you, i dont gain ANYTHING from this product and yet you have a problem with me and call me out in the comments. For what? Im not saying i made this myself, yes, the code is ai generated, but I did make the animations for the crab, I designed the 3d case for(which i also shared for free) so people can use it.
Also, how am I not disclosing it? I also posted the exact same post on ClaudeAI saying that I built this WITH claude.
And I love how you’re straight up just sad because it can do something you can’t - calling it slop simply because it was made by ai?
And yes, I did attach a license to it, because even if the code itself was made by ai - it is MY product and ai is the tool i used to make it. Also it shows you have no idea what youre talking about, because GPLv3 explicitly allows anyone to change, fork and redistribute the code
And again, it’s not an AI companion - it was never in my mind to make it one. I just wanted to have a small monitor on my desk that displayed my PC stats and weather. Calling it that shows that not only have you not reviewed it, im sure as hell you didn’t review the code
Also this is very weird to say. You have no idea who I am. I’m a (now former) professor of computer science, game engineering, and ethics. I worked on large scale production of semiconductors for Apple and HTC when I lived in Taiwan. I can, and have made similar stuff to the device you are showing off, even recently- including the CAD-modeling, which was new for me because I come from a game engineering background in which we generally use Maya.
And yeah, I did it without AI because honestly it’s not that difficult.. Especially now with the ESP32 and Arduino IDE working together it’s borderline plug-and-play.
It’s like eating meat: It’s unethical. You can justify it to yourself, you can be okay with it, but it is in almost every case unethical.
Same goes for using stolen code that’s being sold back to the people that they stole it from and then pretending that you made it.
I appreciate you taking the time for the modeling and the design of the pixel art and such, I hope it’s clear that’s not the parts I’m talking about. I am calling it an AI companion because well, besides it being a large part of its functionality it’s also how it was made: A companion made by AI. The UI looks AI generated, the code is AI generated, hence “AI companion”. I understand that’s not fun to hear and I don’t mean it as an insult. If it has value to you then that’s all it needs to be.
But I do have moral issues with AI projects like these being “given back” to the community it was stolen from in the first place. Then attaching licenses that doesn’t allow AI to steal it basically (but it will, I know because I’ve found my literal code in LLMs including a minor bug I had in one of my open source projects that got fixed later on), then trademarking it and such. I hope you know as well as I do that AI doesn’t give a shit about trademarks. It just consumes everything made by actual people and sells it back to us.
You understand how stupid you sound? Nobody attacked you directly other than pointing out that you did not disclose that you used AI in this post. Talking about another post is really stupid because it is not relevant.
Nobody is sad because you used a code calculator to make a gadget. They are sad that this seems to be the norm now and it is extremely depressing because people like you genuinely believe you are creating something. It is unhealthy.
No reason to waste putting a license to it, I’m sure your Claude agent scraped a bunch of other projects that had licenses anyway. Again, stupid.
It works with a companion app to show you your PC performance and your AI PROJECT PROGRESS/USAGE of course people are going to call it an AI companion…it was built by AI, works with AI.
you can’t really be this stupid?
Made by ai, was the main point. The project is slop, code is a mess. I think the real point is that people use AI to just get something that works, they don’t bother optimizing the code or learning anything themselves, then run and post it like it’s a big deal. I perceived the comment to be pointing out how embarrassing it is to see this kind of stuff being boasted while considering yourself part of the community. One that used to take pride in doing things right, clean, and with our own hands.
You complain a lot
Hi bro, what the ESP32-S3 board called? Does it have a link on aliexpres?
Hi! Of course, its called ESP32-S3-TOUCH-LCD-4.3B. I found it on aliexpress here https://aliexpress.com/item/1005009834535947.html
Just watch out for the color, the -BOX version comes with its own case, which still works but won’t fit in my 3D printed case mentioned on github
Thanks!I already had it in my basket :))
I recomend this, its a esp32 s3 watch, fun gadget
That’s actually so cool! Ill be sure to look it up,
Folks AI is a tool and is not going anywhere. I can just imagine the wood workers when electric saws came out, those using manuals saws were pretty mad that electric saws were taking over. This can be applied to anything. Also I remember In the late 90s… Hey don’t send an email, write the letter and mail it. We humans are funny, we rinse and repeat.
I think this project is pretty cool.
Lol totally nonsensical comparison electrical saws didn’t take cuts made by other saws, put them in different wood, and call them their own. If you don’t know what you’re talking about, it’s better to not.
Just because you don’t get it, it does not mean others don’t get it. 😉
Bro, i also made deskbuddy but for Android phones. We got the same idea https://github.com/Shriaman2005/deskbuddy
That’s really cool, i love the style of it!
Thanks