White oak tone variance
I just finished a white oak hutch using ply and solid. I’ll get a sheet of plywood stamped “white oak” that looks more red than a sheet of stamped red oak ply. There are more than 100 types of white oak in North America alone. I think some look more red than others. Stain or clear coat helps sometimes but for me it just accentuates the color differences. I had to use a toner in my clear coat over stain to get everything more consistent. My approach was to use a little red/brown to make the whiter stuff look a little more red. In my research there’s a way to use green tone to make the red stuff look more white, and a product called red-out. I think white oak is the new walnut now so we all are gonna learn about this soon.
Good to know thanks for all the info!
Looks awesome so far nice joinery.
I was really stressed about it during the process but luckily my client was chill and they had old existing oak flooring in the space that has a lot of variation. I was honest with them as much as I could and had them somewhat sign off on the finish as I went through
Yep. People forget there are so many subspecies of wood that just get grouped together. And nobody should rely on color when differentiating oaks. End grain is the best way.
Can you show us the end grain? Also, do you know what the color variation looks like with finish on it? Any scrap pieces you can test the finish on to see if this is even an issue?
I did some samples with stain and finish, and it doesn’t blend a whole lot better, without using difference stains for different tones
Looks like white oak to me. I think you’re just dealing with different shades of the same wood species
Agree that this is white, not red.
To the original question, I think you might not be seeing the forest through the trees. The first pic looks really obviously different and not great, but the second photo the right edge band looks pretty close to the left edge band in question and then the third photo they look even closer to each other.
I actually quite like the contrast in the edge bands vs the veneer countertop and frame.
How close are you with the client? If you have a decent working relationship, just fire them these pictures and see what they think. If you don’t want to reach out to them then I think you can send it as is, this is one of those things that the crafter notices more than anyone else would!
Oak has a lot of variation.
If you want good match, you can source matched sets (lumber from the same log) or over-buy your material and pick out the best matches.
Good board and grain match is a big part of what separates good woodworking from .. less good. So it’s understandable that it’s bothering you if that’s the kind of product you want to deliver.
white oak does vary a lot board to board, so hand picking at the lumberyard is the right move. i’d match the grain direction too so it reads as one piece
In my experience, I’ve had a lot of varying white oak as well. I’m pretty sure white oak is a grouping of a few different trees considered white oak, so the match isn’t perfect.
If you get to hand pick your lumber at the yard, I’d try to make sure it all comes from the same lift(pallet of boards from the same lumber mill). I do this a lot with cherry as well, because variations are everywhere, but worse in white oak.
White oak is second in terrible pick through to walnut IMO, I try not to build many bigger pieces in white oak. Last was a dining table and it took 3 separate lumber runs, even with getting 10% extra.
That’s the stuff nobody notices until you point it out.
I think you’re just into it too deep. It looks great and I don’t think anyone would notice.
Change it now. You put any kind of finish in it and it will darken. And it looks like it will stick out like crazy. Save yourself the hassle, change it out now and use that piece somewhere else less visible.
It could be an issue for the client. Many understand the natural variation in woods and will be understanding, but some don’t know that there are different species of white oak and this looks like that issue to me with that level of color difference.
I’ve been there, if needed do a two part bleach process.
I made some white oak countertops several months ago. I had two sticks I swore were red oak by the coloration. Coloration varies sometimes in the length of the same board. It’s wood🤔🤪
Doesn’t look like it.
Personally I dont think the tone is different enough to have a big impact. I would just leave it
Whether a client notices comes down to where the odd board sits. A pinkish or darker stile on an open shelf, right next to an olive piece, is exactly what people see first, while the same mismatch on a back panel would vanish. White and red oak also differ in grain, since red has the more open pores and a visible rosy cast, so even a good finish may not hide it if it really is red.
Take a couple of off-cuts of the two that have high contrast, and hit them with platina shellac.
Shellac should remove all pink tones via a natural tannin reaction, but I’m not sure how uniform the final shade will be given how many species there are.
Dewaxed shellac can be used as a base/primer coat for about any finish, so you can use it to tone a piece even if you want a different finish ultimately.
Replace only the one with green tape on it, gtg.
I had to look though before I found the issue, I wouldn’t make you change it if you didn’t point it out.
I couldn’t see it, had to wait for your explanation of which one was different, and even now I can barely see a difference. Its your business and your customer though, it’s really a judgement call that you need to make.
Welcome to working with wood.
That is white oak. White oak comes a tiny bit brown/pink sometimes. Drives me nuts too. Gotta get a consistent distributor.