old - refetching

Heart says Volvo 240 wagon, head says Miata for something I’ll actually drive

I’m torn between two cars that popped up locally and could use some input from people who’ve been in the same spot.

First is a 1988 Volvo 240 wagon with the B230, 5-speed, around 180k miles. Body is straight with minimal rust, interior is worn but usable, and it runs but needs brakes, suspension bushings, and a decent detail. Seller wants \(2,800. The other is a 1997 Miata with the 1.8, 140k miles, hardtop included but the soft top is ripped and the paint is faded. Asking \)3,500.

I already have a daily so this would be the weekend/fun car, but the goal is to sort it out and actually use it instead of it becoming a long-term garage project. The Volvo appeals because it’s practical, cheap to work on, and I could throw a roof rack on it for camping stuff. The Miata would obviously be more fun on twisty roads but I’d probably end up chasing top and interior fixes first.

Anyone gone through a similar choice? Did the “sensible” option end up being the one you regretted not going for, or did the Miata route turn out easier than expected?

jaqattack02
6 | 6 days ago
coyote_of_the_month
3 | 6 days ago
jaqattack02
5 | 6 days ago
CotterMasseuse
6 | 6 days ago
No-Locksmith-9377
5 | 6 days ago
CodewortSchinken
3 | 6 days ago
graytotoro | 2016 Miata
3 | 6 days ago
Standard-Presence305
2 | 6 days ago
yossarian19
2 | 6 days ago
Awhile9722
2 | 6 days ago
GeekBoyWonder
2 | 5 days ago
GeekBoyWonder
2 | 5 days ago
BaconNPotatoes
2 | 6 days ago
KennyGrimes
1 | 6 days ago
EC_CO | 1970 Barracuda
1 | 6 days ago
changingtheoil
1 | 6 days ago
Slight-Implement-427
1 | 5 days ago
Routine-Amphibian450
1 | 5 days ago
trevb75
1 | 5 days ago
blunttrauma99
1 | 5 days ago
Vineless | Volvo Nerd
1 | 3 days ago
good-enoug
1 | 3 days ago