Fun fact: Jacob Misiorowski in 2026 is the first player ever to give up a HR in the first AB of the year and win unanimous Cy Young
I was watching Miz comp on YT and noticed he gave up a HR on his first AB of the year and wondered if such events were common.
So, I decided to search the PBP data on Baseball reference and checked the first game of each unanimous CY winning season. There has been 17 and 14 unanimous CY winning seasons in NL and AL (14 and 10 players each), so it took about 30 min to manually look them up in Bref.
Anyway, here’s the result of the first ABs of each U-CY winning years:
Year
Player
date of 1st game of the year
Team
Team against
1st batter faced
Result of the AB
1963
Sandy Koufax
1963-04-10
LAD
CHC
Lou Brock
Single to P
1965
Sandy Koufax
1965-04-18
LAD
PHI
Cookie Rojas
Single to LF
1966
Sandy Koufax
1966-04-13
LAD
HOU
Lee Maye
Popfly: 2B
1968
Bob Gibson
1968-04-10
STL
ATL
Felipe Alou
Popfly: SS
1972
Steve Carlton
1972-04-15
PHI
CHC
José Cardenal
Groundout: 2B-1B
1984
Rick Sutcliffe
1984-04-03
CLE
TEX
Wayne Tolleson
Groundout: 1B unassisted
1985
Dwight Gooden
1985-04-09
NYM
STL
Lonnie Smith
Flyball: CF (Deep CF)
1988
Orel Hershiser
1988-04-05
LAD
SFG
Brett Butler
Popfly: SS (Short LF)
1994
Greg Maddux
1994-04-04
ATL
SDP
Bip Roberts
Single to SS (Ground Ball)
1995
Greg Maddux
1995-04-26
ATL
SFG
Darren Lewis
Groundout: P-1B (Short 3B Line)
2002
Randy Johnson
2002-04-01
ARI
SDP
D’Angelo Jimenez
Groundout: SS-1B
2007
Jake Peavy
2007-04-03
SDP
SFG
Dave Roberts
Groundout: 1B-P (2B-1B)
2010
Roy Halladay
2010-04-05
PHI
WSN
Nyjer Morgan
Single to SS (Ground Ball to Weak 3B)
2014
Clayton Kershaw
2014-03-22
LAD
ARI
AJ Pollock
Strikeout Looking
2022
Sandy Alcántara
2022-04-08
MIA
SFG
Mike Yastrzemski
Popfly: 2B
2025
Paul Skenes
2025-03-27
PIT
MIA
Xavier Edwards
Strikeout Swinging
2026
Jacob Misiorowski
2026-03-26
MIL
CHW
Chase Meidroth
Home Run (Fly Ball to Deep LF)
Year
Player
date of 1st game of the year
Team
Team against
1st batter faced
Result of the AB
etc
1968
Denny McLain
1968-04-11
DET
BOS
Mike Andrews
Single to SS
1978
Ron Guidry
1978-04-08
NYY
TEX
Mike Hargrove
Single to CF
1986
Roger Clemens
1986-04-11
BOS
CHW
John Cangelosi
Single
1998
Roger Clemens
1998-04-01
TOR
MIN
Otis Nixon
Strikeout Swinging
1999
Pedro Martínez
1999-04-05
BOS
KCR
Carlos Beltrán
Strikeout Looking
Gave up a HR to the very next batter (Joe Randa)
2000
Pedro Martínez
2000-04-04
BOS
SEA
Mike Cameron
Strikeout Swinging
2004
Johan Santana
2004-04-06
MIN
CLE
Ronnie Belliard
Single to CF (Fly Ball)
2006
Johan Santana
2006-04-04
MIN
TOR
Reed Johnson
Groundout: P-1B
2011
Justin Verlander
2011-03-31
DET
NYY
Brett Gardner
Strikeout Swinging
2020
Shane Bieber
2020-07-24
CLE
KCR
Whit Merrifield
Hit By Pitch
2022
Justin Verlander
2022-04-09
HOU
LAA
Shohei Ohtani
Strikeout Swinging
2023
Gerrit Cole
2023-03-30
NYY
SFG
LaMonte Wade Jr.
Walk
2024
Tarik Skubal
2025-03-27
DET
LAD
Shohei Ohtani
Groundout: 1B unassisted
2026
Cam Schlittler
2026-03-27
NYY
SFG
Luis Arraez
Flyball: LF (Short LF)
(all credits to Baseball reference on the PBP data)
Summary: Miz is the first pitcher ever in MLB to give up a HR in his first AB of the year and win unanimous CY in the same year
Significance of this record: Probably none.