I was among a group of people that met with MLB on Thursday to discuss the CBA negotiations, their proposals, and the looming lockout. Here’s what they said.
As a member of the MLB Fan Council, a group of various baseball content creators, freelancers and community leaders from all 30 teams, we’ve met with MLB spokespeople over Zoom to discuss various important issues throughout the year, ranging anywhere from rule changes, to the All-Star game, to how the game is marketed. Thursday’s meeting focused on the ongoing CBA negotiations and MLB’s side of what they’re proposing. We primarily spoke with Glen Caplin, who is MLB’s Special Assistant of Baseball Operations and the regular host of these meetings.
While we have permission to share the contents of our meetings, we’ve been asked not to record them. Thus, I’m mostly going off of memory and off of what I noted to members of my discord community during the meeting. If anyone else who was in the call happens upon this thread and remembers something I missed, please feel free to comment it below.
Of course, it goes without saying that since this was all delivered from an MLB spokesperson, it should be understood that the messaging is inherently designed with MLB bias.
The messaging around this proposal from both sides is, in an ironic way, uniquely reversed from what the public will be used to hearing when it comes to any other CBA negotiation: when it comes to a 50⁄50 revenue split, players are arguing that they already make more than that, while MLB is arguing that players are currently getting less than they could.
One of the attendees raised this point during the meeting; they noted that the MLBPA is claiming they already earn 55% of baseball related revenue (which would make it the most favorable CBA for players of the four major North American sports) and a 50⁄50 split would be a downgrade from that.
Caplin’s response was formulated around some of the following points:
MLB claims that whatever the players are currently earning is a slice of a smaller pie than what can be on the table; MLB is proposing to rework the foundational calculations of what is considered baseball revenue by wrapping in significant new sources that aren’t currently included in that number. An example Caplin gave was including revenue from the complexes and baseball villages being built around many of the newest ballparks.
MLB claims that players have gotten an increasingly smaller share of total baseball spending over each of the last four years. One of the examples we were given to illustrate why and how this is happening is that teams are still spending the same as they always have on overall baseball competitiveness but more and more of that spending is being used on things outside of player salaries, such as stadium upgrades, developmental processes and analytics departments. He pointed out the Rays and Brewers as examples of teams that sit above the league average on non-player spending while being among the lowest in the league on player compensation.
The most significant change to how revenue is interpreted and to the business of baseball as a whole would feature an entirely new centralized calculation of media rights and TV-related revenues. They would do away with the old revenue-sharing system – which only pools 48% of each team’s media revenue – to a new pool of 100% of media-related revenue that is then redistributed evenly. At this point, I asked if they had a path to navigating specific outlier situations like the Dodgers’ bankruptcy exemption or teams like the Blue Jays and Yankees that own their own networks and can sell broadcast rights to themselves at whatever rate they want. Caplin’s response was essentially that he doesn’t know enough about the intricacies of each of those deals to speak on exactly how it would shake out but that he was confident the centralized revenue calculation would feature “all 30 MLB clubs.”
One of the concerns I raised was about potential flexibility at the bargaining table. During the last CBA negotiations, the largest point of contention was the luxury tax, its thresholds, and the related tax penalties, which are conceptually negotiable by nature. They’re simple numbers that can move in either direction. Since a system designed on a 50⁄50 revenue split is inherently immovable, I asked if MLB believes there is actually any room to negotiate and make concessions on their end. Are there areas where the two sides can actually push/pull on or are fans just going to be waiting forever on one side to cave?
Caplin’s response was that there are plenty of areas where the two sides can negotiate on because the cap and floor system they are proposing itself creates new opportunities for movement and concessions in places they previously felt were off-limits.
The two key examples he gave:
The sixth year of control: Players have long wanted to hit free agency sooner and to have teams hold fewer years of control over their initial contracts. This has always been an absolute non-starter for MLB, as they believe it would disproportionately hurt small market teams and further exacerbate any perceived or alleged issues of competitive balance. With a new cap and floor system, having an enhanced environment of parity and a built-in hamstring for the largest spending markets, it’s less potentially damaging to competitive balance to allow players to enter the market sooner.
Another safeguard for smaller market teams to retain leverage over their homegrown players is the qualifying offer system, which Caplin stated has been a contentious enough system on its own that it’s been a sticking point of entire CBA negotiations in the past. MLB has offered to abolish the QO system entirely as part of its latest proposals as it’s another safeguard they don’t believe is as needed in a cap and floor system.
Caplin then plainly stated multiple times that MLB is ready and willing to extensively negotiate further but that, according to him, the players refuse to even come to the table as long as a cap and floor system is being proposed. At least according to Caplin, the players refuse a cap/floor system, still want fewer years of control, and even want the luxury tax thresholds raised with the penalties reduced. MLB’s stance on that is that those changes would further exacerbate the league’s issues with parity.
Another attendee brought up concerns regarding under the table free agency agreements between teams and young international prospects, signed years in advance of their legal signing periods. MLB’s idea is that an international draft with hard slots would completely eliminate the current system of under the table agreements as teams would no longer be able to make any financial guarantees to players or their agents years in advance when they’d be at the mercy of the draft board.
Regarding my own personal bias, the exploitation of minors in the international system by major league teams, family members and local “buscones” has always been my chief concern with baseball; it’s not just another element of the sport, it’s a genuine humanitarian issue. I’ve thought about the topic a lot over the years and since we had the opportunity to speak to people directly involved, I decided to throw out one of the pie-in-the-sky ideas I’ve long dreamt of: a massive, college-style MLB academy, built in the Dominican Republic, funded equally by all 30 teams, where teenaged prospects could attend and receive a certified US high school education by American teachers, take courses in English and financial planning, and graduate into a draft that is backed by an NHL-like central scouting system.
To be clear, this was something I assumed was largely impractical and unrealistic in the near term, I just wanted to put it out into the universe. But in response, we were given a link to MLB’s CBA proposal press/PR site, which details what they’re offering on each topic. Reading over their International Free Agent proposal, I was pleasantly surprised by how much of what I thought was a pipe dream is already being discussed here. It’s obviously not a 1-to-1 to my MLB Hogwarts but it’s far closer than I ever thought I’d see.
I’ve linked the press site here for you all to read from directly, as well as a few of the key notes that stood out most to me:
https://www.mlb.com/level-the-playing-field/fact-sheets/international-player-development
Expand MLB’s existing Amateur Scouting League into a scouting and development league for top draft-eligible players each year. Players would receive housing, meals, a stipend, and educational programs.
Introduce an International Scouting & Medical Combine for the top 300 international prospects each year with a similar format to the MLB Draft Combine for domestic players, which is entering its sixth year.
Provide continued playing and development opportunities for players over the age of 18 who do not sign during their first year of draft eligibility.
Collaborate with governments, federations, independent trainers, and other baseball programs to expand baseball opportunities in players’ hometowns, which would allow the players to remain in school while pursuing careers in baseball.
There is far more information on many other aspects of their IFA proposal at the link (as well as all other systems included in MLB’s overall proposal) but I felt this section was worth highlighting. I hope both sides can agree on at least implementing these changes, regardless of what ultimately ends up happening with the draft and the age of eligibility cutoffs.