MLB’s Case for a Salary Cap, Explained - Trevor May
“The billionaires want more money.”
I saw someone earnestly say they liked the idea of a salary cap because the owners could take the money they saved on payroll and pay for their own stadiums and lower ticket prices.
That’s the kind of genius the pro-cap side is full of
Well, they certainly could. They won’t, but they could.
i’m sure they’ll also use it to give their workers raises and good healthcare!
So, more trickle down economics bullshit.
And there are a ton of people on the anti-cap side who have proven they have zero idea how a cap and floor system works, the nuances of regional supply and demand, etc.
I could say “that’s the kind of genius the anti-cap side is full of.” But I recognize that a few idiots aren’t representative of everybody who takes that position.
Maybe you could work on recognizing the same.
One of the reasons I don’t use a flair is that I don’t want to be lumped in with other Braves fans like you
I’m more than happy to not be lumped in with folks who don’t offer any substantial points of their own and only care about making super sick burns online
Insane that this has downvotes. You said nothing wrong whatsoever here
nice strawman
such a useless way to argue something
Are you under the belief that scarecrows have become sentient, are idiotically pro-cap, and have learned how to post on social media?
“i saw someone say bro”
It blows my mind people look at it this way. Do people here not watch nba/nfl. There’s never a cap proposal without a floor. As the MLB exists right now the teams could just group up and stop giving guys contracts more than the minimum, there’s no legal boundary stopping them from doing that. Cap/floor system is way better for fans and the vast majority of players other than mega star types who are gonna get 100s of millions. They might make marginally less, but with a floor all 30 teams will need to spend so the lower to middle class type players will see their salaries inflated.
The vast benefit to those leagues is in their profit sharing not the floor and cap.
The problem is the current floor proposal from the owners is a joke compared to the NFL/NBA. NFL/NBA floor is 90% of the cap. Owner proposal is 70%, so you could still have teams spending 43% more at the cap than the teams living at the floor. Compare that to only 11% higher under the NFL/NBA cap/floor
If we’re going to be directly analogous to the other leagues, nfl and nba, we’re going to be getting rid of guaranteed contracts. I’d rather have a wider window between the cap and floor and keep guaranteed money
That’s a fair point. Guaranteed contracts definitely a massive plus for the players
And this is somehow worse than the current system where the cheap teams are spending like 20% of the top teams?
No, it’s an incremental improvement, but it’s sure as shit not going to lead to the same parity you seen in the NFL/NBA. Pointing to NFL parity as an argument for the current cap/floor is disingenuous
Did you expect the owner’s first proposal to be where they expect it to ultimately land? If the MLBPA eventually caves on the salary cap (big if), one of the main concessions they would demand in return is increasing the floor to that same 90% range. Both sides know that, but you can’t start by offering it and then have nothing left to negotiate with.
No, but I expect people to recognize that the current floor is a joke until those concessions come.
The CBA doesn’t allow collusion. They can’t group up and decide anything without the PAS approval
By DEFINITION they wouldn’t be proposing this unless they were certain it would make them more money, floor or not.
They don’t have to, so they won’t.
There is no floor right now. The first mlb proposal had the floor at 180 million, which last year exactly half the league spent less than. The cap would be 258 which only 6 teams spend more than. The overall money going to players will go up a ton based on that proposal, and it was only the first offer so can likely be negotiated up as well. 5 teams spent less than 100 million last year it’s pathetic.
Is that still the case when you count all the benefits, draft and IFA bonuses, etc. towards the players’ pool, and then discount things like stadium maintenance like the owners want?
I think a lot of this comes from people who have not yet processed that the salary cap isn’t a fixed amount that never changes. They truly believe the salary cap will be set at $275 million and will stay there forever.
No, nobody thinks that.
We all understand that the owners just want a maximum amount for their payroll every year. That number will change but they want to limit how much they can pay players
they want to limit how much they can have to pay players
Half of the owners will be required to spend more on their rosters next year under their latest offer btw
Plenty of people think that. I’ve seen numerous comments on this sub saying things like “over time owners will keep making more money while players share won’t go up.”
It’s kind of true. The owners will try to find ways to generate money that’s not covered by the salary cap.
Since this will be the daily thread arguing about cap/floor. Here’s the PA’s economic proposals that don’t require a cap:
Qualified free agency for players with five or more years of service who have reached age 30
“Luxury Tax” threshold increases and removal of non-monetary penalties
A new “Competitive Integrity Tax” applying to Clubs that fail to meet minimum payroll benchmarks
Expanded draft lottery to further disincentivize tanking
Additional MLBPA Proposals that are designed to improve competition while also supporting lower revenue Clubs include:
Increased revenue sharing that initially guarantees every small market Club a minimum of $240m in revenue every season, subject to requirements that funds be used to compete on the field. Beyond that guarantee:
Clubs will be able to keep more of the stadium-related revenues they generate
Tens of millions in extra revenue sharing will go to low-revenue Clubs that qualify for the playoffs or have a winning record
Significantly increased sharing of local media revenues from high to low revenue teams
Curbing revenue sharing dependence by barring excessive transfers
Penalties for Clubs that neglect to spend revenue sharing payments on team payroll
Draft picks and other benefits for low revenue Clubs active in free agency and other signings
Competitive integrity tax is just a less effective floor. Like some teams would rather pay the tax than pay players to come up to a floor. Just force them to have a floor.
The NBA floor works the same way and teams almost always get there with actual payroll. Teams don’t want to spend money on nothing
yea. but they also have a cap.
a floor by itself doesn’t really solve any problem - at least from a fan perspective. especially a soft floor
all the top free agents would still go to the same 3 teams.
the only thing that would change is players like Josh Bell getting a bit more money.
which is cool. but, not really an issue tbh
Advocating for the lowest paid members seems like literally entirely the point of having a union that advocates for it’s members. The stars don’t need advocacy.
NBA has a luxury tax. Individual player contracts are capped, but team payroll isn’t.
The thing about the lux tax is that it gets more expensive as you exceed it. The CIT would work the same way. After a year or two you’re spending more on the tax than you are saving by not signing / extending quality players.
Like some teams would rather pay the tax than pay players to come up to a floor.
Guess what the penalty is for being under the floor in the owners’ proposal…
Not if it comes with a cap. We already have a luxury tax there should be a bottom feeder tax.
Do people actually think they will enforce the floor as much as the cap? At least it’s there.
The irony here is that the MLBPA’s proposals sound like right wing neoliberalism, increasing opportunities for “small(er) businesses” and cracking down on welfare fraud (e.g. The Marlins) while in comparison the owners sound like the Democratic Socialists of America, cracking down on big business (e.g. the Dodgers and Yankees) and redistributing the revenue to everyone equally.
WTF are you babbling about? Do you think the NFL is DSA? The NFL model is THE sports model. How can GB…population 100k compete with places like NY and LA? They treat all teams as a single business instead of 30 separate ones. Why? Because the dodgers can’t exist without Tampa or Miami or Pitt…in true capitalism the spending gap that has widened by what 300% will only continue to get worse and worse…and in true capitalism…the dodgers would absorb their competition. You think that’s what should happen here? GMAFB. Your post is so far out there that I am truly embarrassed for you and your college(doubt it) professors.
It appears that you did not understand what I said. Just own that, rather than acting like its anyone’s fault but your own.
Thats exactly because right wing neoliberal policies don’t actually address root cause issues or systemic problems and are by design status quo… which is what the MLBPA has offered to date.
What are you talking about man
This is going to be the ad naseum topic literally until baseball comes back. It’s already soooooo tiring and repetitive.
What purpose does the red arrow serve
It points to the guy
Points to the problem.
The Problem: Morgan Sword
Pointing out that man’s name is Salary Cap
But the other guy is the one wearing a cap
It’s pointing out an extra long hair the red-headed man didn’t catch while shaving.
It tells us the thumbnail was designed with SEO in mind.
Thumbnails have little to do with SEO.
Thumbnails are about getting high CTR on the homepage so that it gets pushed to more people on their own homepage.
You might not know where to look otherwise, obviously
May’s point on the difference in wins was one of the most disingenuous arguments in this entire discussion yet. A 10% swing in games is huge for a non-skill advantage.
In what world is a 10% advantage NOT a major factor? I lost my shit at this point
Cap without floor only depressed wages. Floor without cap only drives up costs of doing business without the assurances against still being massively outbid for talent. Why anyone advocates for one without the other doesn’t make sense.
Imo the owners have a better idea in mind than the union does. The league needs competitive balance. It’s not just billionaire greed.
The Dodgers earn $300 million more annually on their local TV deal than the Marlins do theirs. That’s bad for baseball and not a cheap ownership issue.
Much more revenue sharing is needed but you need a floor to ensure teams are actually spending that money. But as you point out, a floor with no cap just inflates the wages of the better free agents to meet the minimum threshold. That’s why revenue sharing, cap and floor, are all needed.
The owners aren’t doing it for competitive balance tho they’re doing it to not have to put up money. Maybe that’s the reason fans want it, and that’s okay but I don’t know why anyone would think the owners are about competitive balance in the sport. We saw how they reacted to the Astros situation.
If they were serious about integrity they would propose a much higher floor.
What the owners are proposing absolutely would achieve competive balance in a healthy way that would improve MLB as an entertainment product and enhance the viability of all 30 markets.
Of course they want more money for the league and themselves, but competitive balance is integral in achieving that. And I fully believe fans want the competitive balance. This sub is a a bit of an echo chamber at times.
I’m not pro owner by any stretch but what they propose is absolutely better for the game than what the union wants.
what is competitive balance in a healthy way?
how would it do that?
Nope owners can fix the majority of it with better revenue sharing. Absurd to say “we need you to take the hit so we can police ourselves”
The owners have 0 interest in competitive balance. Not one ounce. They want to spend less money and make more money. Having doormats is perfectly acceptable to them because to them, they’re just fodder to feed to the big market teams.
If the owners cared about competitive balance, they would punish teams who show up for their revenue sharing check. They’d instutue a draft lottery where 9 picks are shared amount 10 teams, so if you’re recod is bad, you might lose out on a pick.
They’d stop giving resources to teams who habitually sign slap-dick players an trade away anyrhibg of value at mid-season.
There has to be a pretty substantial increase in profit when a team makes a deep push into the playoffs, no?
I doubt it. They don’t get any extra television money for playing in the postseason - that’s all shared. The extra stadium revenue and perhaps radio revenue is pretty small; it’s not that many games even if the tickets are more expensive.
A competitive team can lead to more revenue in future seasons, if they can maintain the success. But attendance gains tend to trail behind on-field success, and a poor start to the next season can have a major negative impact on that.
But that involves risk. Safer to simply slash payroll to nothing and reap the profits of other teams successes.
Except good teams usually command higher ticket prices so it still interests owners to be competitive
Or you can dick ride the teams that are trying.
Ultimately,the problem is the owners who are just here to cash checks. Punish them and the product improves considerably.
In a 50⁄50 like the NFL or NHL how can the owners make more money if it is equally distributed?
Can you show me how the NFL has been negatively affected by a cap? Please…I’ll wait…
Let’s see… The cap necessitates that players can be cut at any time and get $0. Contracts mean nothing, and literally every player is a journeyman, and no one knows who plays on any team in any given year. Of course, this leads to a bunch of players who have to not play in order to get any kind of compensation that isn’t complete peanuts for the coming year. None of the players earn anywhere near what they’re worth, since one position takes up all the cap space.
But at least we have the level playing field of… the same two teams representing the AFC for basically the last 25 years.
Of course, there is the fairness of a 50⁄50 split, and it’s not like the owners would try to take things like stadium costs, personnel, player development, management fees, taxes, and any number of other expenses off the top, so that of the 12 billion or so that MLB brings in, somehow the revenue is actually only about 2 billion, that gets splits 50⁄50 between the owners and the player. Don’t ask to see the books on that though, it’s none of your god damned business. I’m sure we haven’t seen that kind of creative accounting in entertainment industries before.
Competitive balance is just fine actually there are simply 6, 7, 8 or 9 ownerships who have actually opted out of pursuing fielding a winning ballclub (the marlins are sadly are one of them).
World series winning heritage not to far in the past + 7th or 8th largest city in america by the way. Blame your shitty owners and inept baseball decision makers.
I understand the point but constantly using the Marlins v LAD argument sucks. It like celebrating that your tax accessor kept your annual property tax lower because your neighbor built a double wide trailer on their property In lieu of a “proper” home.
Bruce Sherman has a net worth of $1.3 billion dollars. If he doesn’t want to pay the players on the field he should sell the team to someone who will.
I suggest you educate yourself on how league finances work and educate yourself on what net worth actually means. The Dodgers don’t outspend the Marlins that much because their owners are richer or because they are more prone to digging into their own pockets.
The payroll discrepancy between teams can be tightly correlated with revenue discrepancy.
Literal facts about how league finances work.
Bruce Sherman had enough capital to buy a professional sports team in 2018. He wasn’t some inheritance baby who the game priced out. He knew what he was getting into and their payrolls have been pathetic for a guy who bought a major league team within a decade
Why won’t owners share their revenue more fairly? How is that player issue?
Net worth does not mean liquid assets. Stop picturing a vault with heaps of money; it’s the valuation of various business interests. No, Bruce Sherman is not poor, but no, that does not mean infinite money supply for baseball operations.
Also the dodgers are spending half a billion a year. He’s gonna do what? Dip into his own pocket for 3 years and then be broke?
It’s a bad look for this sub that your post is being downvoted. Holy shit.
It’s being downvoted because literally nobody is advocating for one without the other. May spent like 15 seconds in the video talking about how it’s not a law of nature that that a cap always comes with a floor, but the league is not proposing a cap without a floor and the PA is not promoting a floor without a cap.
This is a labor relations sub now.
As it should be.
K
Love trevor on rates and barrels but unfortunately i think this explaination is a bit clumsy because he’s assuming the audience knows about key parts of the whole fiasco that are being kept on the low (such as the “additional future ventures” thing which is just enormous in the calculus of all this).
Still, the fact is the owners have unity and message disipline for probably the first time ever and its going to be an ugly ugly fight. I just urge any fans to not fall for their bullshit pr campaigns. They aren’t just stretching the truth they are lying by omission on most of their key points. The most prominent being the game has little parity or is in an unhealthy place.
I think they should change international amateur signings from free agency to a draft. Have it work similar to the Rule 4 draft in terms of draft order, competitive balance and compensation picks, draft pick penalties for exceeding CBT thresholds, bonus pools, etc..
This would be a massive competitive balance equalizer and it would help protect the players from some of the shadiness that occurs under the current system.
And have teams divest from developing youth baseball and training facilities like they did in PR when it became part of the draft?
They need to restructure international signings but a draft isn’t the answer for that.
I didn’t say to make it part of the rule 4 draft, I said make a draft similar to it. Keep everything about eligibility the same but change the mechanism for entry to a draft.
Trevor May will not give an unbiased opinion.
What would an unbiased opinion even be? aren’t opinions by definition subjective and thus subject to biases?
The most unbiased opinions would probably come from non-baseball fans that are fans of sports that have a salary cap.
However, the opinions I care about the least are the ones that actively benefit from there NOT being a cap/floor. LA/NY/and a couple other big market fanbases. Yeah, no shit a majority of those fans don’t want a cap… their teams are the ones with unlimited resources.
Well, also you don’t care about the opinions of the players i guess
There is a common misunderstanding of how salary caps work. They don’t mean less money for players, as both the NFL and NBA saw player salaries increase after implementing a cap.
The purpose of a cap is to provide cost certainty. The reason the owners are pushing for one is the Los Angeles Dodgers. Their payroll+tax has increased by 93% in just five years, leaving them far ahead of anyone else. The other owners want to rein the Dodgers in, but they aren’t allowed to do so without the union’s permission.
Incorrect on all fronts. Players will indeed make less money, that’s the point, and the whole purpose is for ownership to keep more of the money fans pay in and pay less in salaries. You have listed some excuses ownership provides but those are just smoke and mirrors.
Incorrect on all fronts. Players will indeed make less money
I like how you just make a blanket statement insisting that I’m wrong despite the NBA and NFL both proving me correct. Salary caps do not reduce the amount of money going to the players. The owners’ proposal would result in an increase in the amount of MLB revenue that currently goes to the players.
the whole purpose is for ownership to keep more of the money fans pay in and pay less in salaries.
No, the purpose is cost certainty. It’s to bring down spending by the top teams and bring up spending from the bottom teams.
You have listed some excuses ownership provides but those are just smoke and mirrors.
Did the NFL players’ and NBA players’ share of league revenue increase or decrease after implementation of a salary cap in those leagues? Please answer that question.
How would a true 50⁄50 split have the players make less money?
Yeah, people against the cap don’t mention it a lot but the players just need to negotiate a 50⁄50 split and open books. Right now they’re getting ~50% of what owners report and the owners get the rest. Agree to a cap and floor but demand 51% and open accounting. Then we’ll see how much owners really care about competitive balance.
Kinda curious about this argument cause I’ve seen it a few times, but in what sense do they not have cost certainty now? No one is required to spend any money (except competitive balance transfer stuff), so is it just that they want to discipline the rich owners and let the “poor” owners win?
Like I’ve always viewed this particular fight being more about what is considered “revenue” to the players - there is a number and format out that with a cap and floor that the PA would accept, but we know how these stadium deals have turned into real estate dev instead of improving the game. But I don’t really buy a general cost certainty argument except as it relates to a power struggle within ownership.
The Dodgers and to a lesser extent the Mets spending so much affects the rest of the market. It not only reduces the amount of available free agents, it also results in those other free agents wanting bigger deals. Even if the remaining teams don’t budge, the players and agents wanting more means that those deals probably don’t get made until spring training has already started, which means delayed integration into the roster and no influence on any offseason work the new team may have wanted the player to do.
The Dodgers made $600 million more in revenue than the Brewers in 2025. That’s why the finances in MLB are fundamentally broken. Obviously, the Brewers won a championship anyway, but every winter they lose a key member of their team while every winter the Dodgers keep all their key players and add another team’s key players.
Ok but this has nothing to do with cost certainty in the sense that all contracts they offer are their choice, and stuff like a cap (and a floor) will not change the revenue mismatch. In fact, the PA has suggested that sort of revenue sharing because it doesn’t really affect player salaries.
Usually when we are talking about cost certainty it has to do with needing that baseline because they dont want price fluctuations on needed inputs - baseball contracts are not required in the same way because the input prices are very different. Unless the goal is to reduce player salaries, of course.
Ok but this has nothing to do with cost certainty
You don’t understand how a cap on spending has something to do with cost certainty? Teams don’t want to see another team’s spending increase by 93% in five years. They want a general idea of how much each team will be spending in the near future, which is what the salary cap allows in the NFL and NBA. You not only have a sense of what you will spend, you also know what the other teams in your division are likely to spend.
In fact, the PA has suggested that sort of revenue sharing because it doesn’t really affect player salaries.
You could not possibly be more wrong about this. The MLBPA does not want any revenue sharing at all. That’s why their latest proposal was for revenue sharing to make up the difference for any organization whose baseball related revenue fell below $240 million.
There are no organizations whose baseball related revenue fell below $240 million.
Proposing something that wouldn’t apply to anyone is a way to fool fans like you into thinking that the union supports revenue sharing, because they know that fans overwhelming support revenue sharing.
My brother in baseball, read a fucking economics book or something
I’m completely against a cap at this point. I think the game is actually in a pretty good spot in terms of competitive balance wherein the best managed teams that are well rounded, take good care of the players, coach resposibily, and make solid trades are the teams that are most likely to win. Sure, it doesn’t hurt to have more money, but I honestly think that there’s more to winning than the money and some of the strongest pro-cap people seem to think that money wins the world series.
Hard disagree because year-to-year balance is an exceptionally narrow view against 40 years of data and the fact that exceptional management isnt a thing that you just uniquely have absent of money.
Exceptional management + money will always be better than exceptional management. And money will always create resilience year-to-year in even half-competent organizations.
Literally money is a completely out of scope advantage.
it’s actually insane that i’m seeing so many Brewers fans that after finally winning literally a single world series think that means there aren’t balance issues lol.
Like think of how many things had to go perfectly to create your team, meanwhile we have an abysmal farm and development system and can brute force our way into at least being competitive year-in-and-year-out through mostly money.
Like no one has ever said that a lower payroll team can’t win a WS or be competitive, but overall it is much much less likely.
Brewers fans right now are the meme of the guy in third place spraying champagne in his face. I’m happy they won the title, but let’s be real, the rich teams have always and will always win way more than the poor teams.
and that is the case in every single sport over time. May is right in that regard, this is a business and you are supposed to put money into a business. Even in the capped sports, the teams that consistently go up to the cap and even do shennanigans to get over the cap somehow will always win more than the teams that are constantly at the floor when looked at over a longer time horizon.
And yet the brewers have made the post season 8⁄10 years while the Phillies 5⁄10.
Fair, but using these one or two team anecdotes is beside the point. Just look at the bulk numbers of what teams make the playoffs over the past several decades
Now do the dodgers
HUH? The Rays would easily have the best starting 5 pitchers in baseball if they could afford to keep them.
The fans are at a critical mass…sick of big money teams poaching their players.
The cap is coming and a 50⁄50 rev split is too. It’s fair. It is time.
Hell yeah man. Totally agree.
Bad teams are where they are because of how they are run, not because there isn’t a salary cap.
Hypothetical for you: if every team was equally well run, who would come out on top more often; the teams with more or the teams with fewer resources?
No cap ever. Only accept a cap if owners will accept a cap on how much they can make.
The “70% of fans want a cap and floor” is a particularly egregious piece of propaganda by MLB owners. In part because it’s a very cheery picked stat and in part because being mislead to automatically believe the current state of the business of MLB is worse than it actually is. They don’t know that a cap wouldn’t force cheap owners to spend. They don’t know that a floor wouldn’t prevent cheap owners from cutting non-payroll expenses. They don’t know that “small market” teams already get hundreds of millions of dollars from the rest of the league under the current setup. You’re seeing a vibe that MLB is super broken. What you’re not seeing is open books to prove that MLB is broken because odds are pretty high that all MLB teams are actually profitable.
I think that most fans would like a cap and floor, but with very different numbers than what the owners propose.
Yeah, I think if the PA went up to Rob Manfred and said yes to their floor/ceiling argument but we are setting it \(350mil min and \)500mil max with annual 5% escalators MLB would cry poor.
It’s wild you think setting the floor at the current top spending levels is a valid offer.
I was making numbers up, but the point was that the owners aren’t going to agree to a real floor that is relative to a cap.
Even teams that “lose money” aren’t really losing money. There are many ways to hide profits when you have multiple interconnected businesses being operated by essentially the same people. The Braves used to hide a lot of stuff by selling their broadcast rights for a lower price than they could have gotten in an open process. That meant that the profits were being made by TBS instead of the Braves, but both were basically Ted Turner.
There’s also stadium operations that can be used like that, or you can put a bunch of relatives on the payroll, etc. None of it is illegal, but it’s stuff that doesn’t show up in the carefully crafted financial information that the owners release to the public.
And none of that even gets into the constantly rising franchise values.
Agreed, would need to see the actual numbers. Was the fan base sample representative? Or did they ask 2200 pirate fans what they think.
LMAO like anyone has ever given a fuck about us or what we think. Be real
It seems the goal post always gets moved. first we are talking playoffs now we are talking playoff results.
Money gives you opportunities not guarantees. Otherwise the Mets, Phillies and Yankees would have more in this short time frame.
No shit Sherlock
The fact that you know this and do not see the clear problem is staggering
Yes but you are arguing about results. Totally different things the Brewers have outperformed Yankees, Phillies, Mets so again I state my original premise that this whole argument is overblown. Money might make a difference but not as much as is being portrayed.
Is this some idiot argument where you cant keep multiple things in mind at the same time and are trying to dissect details so that you can be “right” while missing the forest for the tree?
Spending money is a thing. You can’t expect to not spend on your team and make the playoffs. But the degree of spending is debatable. Trying to argue that teams shouldn’t have to invest in their product to field a good team is disingenuous.
I know you just want to be right and are resorting to calling names because surprise not everyone sees it your way. Feel free to sit this one out if you can’t discuss in civil manner
Fuck the greedy owners, fuck a salary cap. A salary floor would be good
A floor without a cap is a nonstarter
so where’s the soft floor then given we have a soft cap?
Do you work for the owners? Why are you being their mouthpiece?
No, probably just someone that understands a floor without a cap, or vice versa, usually does not achieve the goal of competitive balance or evening the playing field in terms of spending.
Or that it’s not even a realistic option. No side is going to agree to one without the other, if at all. Just utterly useless to suggest otherwise
Cap doesn’t achieve that either, your drinking the company Kool aid
This is the take I’m not seeing enough of. I can’t understand why some people are making the players out to be these struggling blue collar union boys. The minimum salary for an MLB player is $780k a year. Forgive me if I couldn’t give less of a shit about their salaries.
Wow you must hate baseball if you hate all the players
Salary cap is for loser un-American sports.
Which is why all major American sports use it other than baseball? Weird take.
MLB is the only league where the Players Union can give a middle finger to the owners on a massive proposal like this and don’t get punished for it. Doesn’t get more American than that ngl.
Because they aren’t as American as baseball.
I’m mostly joking but a salary cap is for real just owners trying to limit expenses.
100%. They know there’s always going to be one owner at least that can’t help themselves, so what better way to limit to damage and promise steady growth than a cap on expenses?