Breaking: The Mets have agreed to an 8-year extension with OF AJ Ewing, according to a person familiar with the situation. Club option for a ninth.
LETS GO
EXTEND BENGE
Would like to see that but Benge is probably on another tier. Doubt he does it.
Not that the Mets really need to choose, but I think Ewing is going to be a better player than Benge in the long term. He’s better in the field and on the bases and I think the gap between them offensively is going to shrink over time. Ewing is 2 years younger as well.
lol idk about that but I like the optimism
Defense at a premium position + speed give Ewing a much higher floor
Was I watching a different Carson Benge steal 22 bases and lead the national league in outfield assists?
Double the money for Benge
$190m/16yrs
190 year legacy contract for his great grandkids
Nah, I LOVE Benge and he was phenomenal last year, but Ewing is a 21 year old CF with elite strike zone command and swing decisions, and more pop to come into.
With Benge, it’s more bc of his age. He’s going into his age 24 season. So a contract like this would take him to 31-32, which he doesn’t want. They could maybe find a middle ground where they buy out one of his FA years, but he’s gonna want to hit FA before he turns 30.
It could also depend on the results of the new CBA
Benge also has a bit more financial security as he got a \(4M signing bonus compared to Ewing's \)675k.
He can afford a bit more risk in betting on himself.
GIVE HIM ALL MONIES!!
You needed to do that before he came up
$95m/8yrs
Pretty damn good
We will find out in about 5 years if its a good deal or not. A lof of these are not working out all that well for the teams.
But we all forget the bad ones and point to the good ones as a reason its smart.
From a fan perspective, its great though. Having a guy in your uniform for 1-3 extra year beyond original club control is soothing.
Even the bad ones though aren’t really bad enough to matter. Like oh fuck the red sox have to pay kristian campbell 7.5 million a year for the next 7 years, that’ll really hamstring them, oh fuck the mariners gave evan white 24 million over 6 years, they could’ve signed juan soto with that
6/24m will forever bring Scott Kingrey back to the front of my memory… man I thought we had one!
When it costs you more money than it would have if you didn’t do it, its objectively a bad deal.
Just because it isn’t the end of the world if it fails, it doesn’t make it a good deal.
But there are those too. Wander, Strider, Homer Bailey etc. There’s just as many that are a total shit show.
Even a lot of the ones we think are brilliant cheap deals really aren’t working out financially. Ronald Acuna Jr has been worth about \(15m-\)20m less during his extension years than his contract for example.
Its a risk reward. But we kinda collectively ignore the risk and just instantly assume they are all great deals. When they really aren’t.
Would I have done all the above mentioned extensions? Absolutely. But that still doesn’t mean they worked out.
100%, people don’t understand risk has value, for both sides, players risk flaming out and never getting big money so they exchange potential earnings to get rid of that risk, teams in that scenario take on risk for potential savings later. We should all be glad people have a choice in this scenario and not just focus on oh man if only you bet on black 6 times in a row you would be looking at a Skubal contract!
Kevin Kiermaier had a 79 wRC+ in some years after he signed his extension with Tampa and was still great value at a little under 9m a year. In the case of Ewing, a little under 12m a year (in 10 years later money) for a great defensive CF through the entirety of his 20s is likely to be as good a deal at minimum
Is he worth 3 times Myles Straw? Because it’s a few years later but over three times as much as that team control extension for a high quality defensive CF with extremely limited power.
At the time of signing Straw was 27 and Ewing is 22. Straw posted an average exit velo of 87.1 and an average hard-hit rate of 26.2% in the season prior while Ewing posted averages of 89.6 and 42.3% respectively. He also almost tripled Straw’s HR total from 2021 in 146 fewer PA.
You’re right that there’s always a chance Ewing’s offense craters (god forbid). But the Mets are banking that those underlying metrics will allow him to be a league average bat and I would agree
It’s a no brainer for Ewing. He’s a very good player. Sign now–take 90 million–why take the chance. He might be a 20 HR guy tops–so his ceiling wasn’t going to be as high as many other young players.
I’m glad for AJ–he seems like the nicest kid who just wants to play baseball.
If I’m a player I’m taking the deal every single time.
Always happy for these kids to lock down generational wealth when you don’t know the future.
I think Soto is the only one who didn’t take the deal and it worked for him.
Can’t think of other guys passing it up yet regretting.
I think it’s wise to go with risk-avoidance when you’re getting close to \(100M for the safe route, but he is potentially leaving over \)100M on the table if he takes a big step forward.
Alonso turned down an extension and before the 2025 season it was looking like a big mistake but betting on himself was pretty lucrative.
Of course there are a lot of cautionary tales. Michael Conforto is probably kicking himself for turning down the extension the Mets offered.
Ewing at least has an MLB season under his belt and his defensive value makes this a no-brainer. Not to mention, if a better CF appears it will be a much easier deal to move even if he’s just a league-average-ish player.
Kristian Campbell
Never been a better time in the league to be a young top 100 prospect player. SO many extensions
He’s not just a prospect anymore, he just put up a 3 WAR rookie season when he only got called up in May
It’s not just rookies getting rewarded. The Brewers extended Cooper Pratt and Luis Lara before they even got called up
Mariners with Colt Emerson as well
This is why you can’t rely on free agency to build a team,
Bingo.
And Chourio
And Jon Singleton and Scott Kingery
Didn’t him finishing top 3 give them a Prospect promotion pick too?
I think top 2 for that but I might be wrong. And I think you have to start the year in the big leagues for it.
I’m pretty sure it’s only for the first place winner actually. I’d love to be wrong and get a pick bc of Benge, but I think it’s ROY winner or top 3 in MVP or Cy Young.
Prospects used to chase extensions. Now extensions chase prospects.
8 years $95M is an incredible deal even for a pre-arb player. And his defensive value makes him a pretty high floor player, he had a 3 WAR rookie season even with a big slump towards the end. Can’t remember the last time the Mets made an extension like this, this fucking rocks
I think Juan Lagares was the last time they did this
My GOAT
JUANNY BEISBOL.
Well we did try with a certain 1st baseman who now plays for the Baltimore Orioles
He was so offended he fired his agent and hired Scott Boras!
Worked out in the end for him at least.
Wasn’t quite the same since it wasn’t pre-arb, he was almost a FA at that point
Oh thats fucking sweet
An Ewing in New York?
Sounds good.
Needs to wear 33
Dillon Jones respect 🫡
Definitely one of those still use “a” situations
A Ewing*
Better than a McEwing at least
Not exactly.
He’ll have to hope no Hakeem goes to another NL East team
So constant playoff beatdowns by the Cubs? I’m for it.
lol never seen an “an” before a last name before, that’s a first ha
LETS GOOO HUGE HOMEGROWN EXTENSION! Vindication! Happy for him and his family. MET!
95/8yrs is cheap. He had his struggles at the plate but still put up a solid season. Even if it doesn’t pan out that’s not a bad contract to get out of.
What’s really encouraging is he went through those struggles in July and August, fought through it and bounced back with a strong September.
He has just guaranteed himself a baseball career that around 10% of players ever achieve.
He is set up for life, will have made 100m by the time he is in his mid 30s.
There are still question marks in his game, but this is a win win for sure. The Mets will be set, at least defensively, in cf for the next decade.
It’s not cheap. It’s a very rich contract for a guy that’s not a free agent for 6 more years.
Slightly less then 12 mil AAV really isn’t that much in the baseball world
As usual, most people don’t understand baseball economics. This is one of the richest contracts ever given to a domestic player with this little service time. AAV is irrelevant. He’s not a FA. He’s 6 years away! They could literally pay him almost nothing next 2 years. Then arb years cheap. This is a fair deal but it’s far from cheap in baseball economics.
But then he could leave. As usual, smug people on Reddit can’t see the big picture. This is a great deal for the Mets.
His floor is his defense and baserunning. Even if he doesn’t hit how we want the Mets barely lose out on the contract due to that floor
He has to hit more to be a starter long term.
I’m legitimately shocked he didn’t hold out and bet on himself but I guess players are worried about a cap. So this has me fucking ecstatic. Lock up Benge and the outfield is set for a long, long time.
Peak Braves org move from the Mets. Well done.
Listen, man. I get it. But please delete this comment.
This is me in MLB The Show.
Sign top prospects to an 8 year team friendly deal.
Stearns is cooking!
Lock up young talent. No brainer
Did he donate 1% to the Atlanta Braves Organization?
more extensions pls
Benge is the one they needed to lock up
Por qué no los dos?
Benge is coming off an amazing season whereas Ewing has a great floor and could be much better than the performance he just put up. They just bought low on Ewing whereas they could be buying high on benge.
Need to lock up both. Benge will be harder to convince.
And Nolan
With his age, it’s hard to find a perfect middle ground for both sides right now.
Wait, did the Knicks just sign their point guard to play center field? I’m so fucking confused lol.
See for the teams that can afford it, it might not seem sexy but it really is the time to lock up the young guys. Unless you don’t think they’re going to end up very good or they don’t fit the culture, they will only end up getting more expensive. Overpay a little now even, just to make it happen. I would love to see more small market teams doing this now though. Worst case, even if you are cheap and sell off, that contract will look very valuable to another team.
Hell yeah
Oh thank fuck. I was worried it was Benge. That dude’s gonna torture us for years to come.
You guys stole Murphy from us, and he tortured us for years, being in Washington!
It was only 2 1⁄2.
Yeah, but it was a LONG 2 1⁄2! I was at plenty of those Mets-Nats games at Nats Park where Murphy went off on the Mets
Not long enough if you ask me.