[Talkin’ Baseball/Janes] Mets have locked up A.J. Ewing to an eight-year extension, per @chelsea_janes
Fantastic deal. Now do Benge
lol everyone in the Mets sub (including me & my brother) said this
locking up ewing for eight years at that number feels like a steal if he keeps trending up
and McLean
How much pricier would benge be? Assuming it’s 8 years too… maybe 110?
Corbin Caroll contract but more because Caroll didn’t have a 3⁄4 WAR season before signing his extension.
More like 200
No way. Carrol got 111… no way benge would even pass 150
For 8 years? That’s crazy, lol. You have to remember that teams have these guys under team control for a while. What you are essentially buying is a few extra years before they can hit FA in exchange for paying them more per year than they would otherwise make, at least until they hit arbitration. Even if Benge stays on his current course, he’ll likely make less than 45 million dollars in the 5 years before he hits free agency. So if you gave him 200 million dollars for 8 years, you are essentially valuing those extra 3 years at over 50 million dollars per year. Idk what the market looks like in 2032, but it’s likely he would accept a 5⁄150 deal once he hits FA, even if he continues to produce 4 WAR seasons. You have to be realistic about what those extra 3 years of control are worth from the team’s perspective versus simply allowing him to play out his pre arb and arbitration years and then trying to work out an extension once he has proven he can consistently produce. In this case, the team would be taking on all the risk associated with one of these extensions with not only none of the reward, but perhaps actually going into the red and paying him even more than he would be expected to make once he’s a free agent. So 8 years/200 million just doesn’t make financial sense whatsoever from a team’s perspective.
Reminds me of the Cubs with the Horner/PCA extensions.
I’m not fully sold on his bat yet, but this is a good deal for him and the team. GG caliber glove, great speed, sneaky pop.
yeah his plate discipline was really good for most of the year outside of one bad month iirc. i completely get why youd wanna lock down an amazing defender who can draw walks pretty well at 21 years old. loootta upside.
Locking up young talent on the cheap is a no brainer. Dude gets paid good and the club get to see his potential
We love it, Benge next.
Watched him in Syracuse. Helluva deal for the Mets.
Steal of the century
Oh thank fuck. I was worried it was Benge. that dude’s gonna terrorize us.
Benge is gonna want a LOT more money
Benge?
I’d be surprised if Benge didn’t get one too at this point. He was the best rookie in the class last year and he’s got a lower ceiling than Ewing but a higher floor.
It’s the other way around – Benge probably has a higher ceiling given the power he’s demonstrated. Ewing still has to show it. At the same time, Benge’s floor is a bit lower as Ewing’s defense can carry him a bit more as a CF.
I think your opinion is the opposite of the consensus but you’re entitled to it!
I disagree and think yours is the opposite, but yeah, you’re entitled to it as well.
I would say my datapoints are Benge being the higher drafted prospect, the one who debuted first (owing to his status in the org), and the one who was ranked more highly during his time as a prospect. You don’t get all that with just a high floor.
Benge also was in the running for ROY. If you believe Ewing has a higher ceiling, that certainly goes against what available evidence we have industry wide.
i think both arguments have valid arguments the defense argument he used is valid bc if they both suck offensively in the future ewing can bat 9th and still provide value
Ewing has shown the power potential already. You have to consider where he was in his development when he was called up - Benge had more time to marinate in the minors, Ewing was still figuring things out offensively.
Overall, Ewing has a much higher ceiling, partially due to his defense just being more valuable, but specifically because his hit tool ceiling is WAY higher than Benge. He hits the ball harder. He makes better contact. He makes better swing decisions. And perhaps most importantly, he’s 2 years younger.
It’s possible that he never puts it all together and Benge has the better major league career. But if we’re evaluating their ceilings, Ewing’s ceiling is MVP candidate, Benge more so regular all star caliber. Baseball prospectus Mets pod talks about this pretty frequently, highly recommend checking them out.
Uhh, you know Ewing played significantly more minors games than Benge, right? 251 v 130. You can say Benge is older but only by about 18 months.
Their EVs are pretty similar but Benge has demonstrated a better LA, makes sense given his swing.
Benge is also an elite fielder in his own right and very fast as well. Benge could hack it pretty well in CF even if Ewing is better.
Look I hope they’re both stars but Benge’s “ceiling” is probably higher.
I don’t know who Benge’s agent is but because his ceiling is very high–
that’s where the unnecessary greed kicks in–unfortunately.
Wow. That’s a really good deal for the Mets. Good for Ewing of course. $95 million is life changing.
Makes you wonder how much Benge would go for.
I wish the Jays had anyone we believed in this much off rip
We have kissed a lot of frogs, to be honest.
Not like this, at least. Honestly cannot remember the last time the Mets were this aggressive in extending a player. Hope they take the same approach with McLean.
I just mean we have had a lot of exciting prospects never really becoming players worth believing in to this extent.
Good for them. I like Ewing and think he’s gonna pan out pretty well for them
Very nice for Ewing and the Mets!
Why 8? Dear God these teams love just keeping people forever, including the one I root for.
He’s only 22.
Yeah I get that he’s young but man 8 years is a long ass time. It’s a deal if he ends up being what they hope.
They bought out 3 years of free agency