6 Best CF’s in the last 60 years
It’s Griffey’s birthday today!
(ノ◕ヮ◕)ノ*:・゚✧
Guess that means it’s Stan Musial’s bday too!
The prides of Donora!
It’s also Stan Musial’s, the other guy who was born on November 21st in Donora, Pennsylvania.
…the other lefthander….
1 Lofton. Put him in the Hall.
2 Dawson, for reasons I get at below
4 After spending far too much time comparing his HoF candidacy to Andre Dawson’s, I know Beltran and Dawson are the same, but Beltran walked more, so this is Beltran
5 Griffey hit 630 home runs
6 Andruw Jones, Dawson/Beltran HRs minus the steals, lower average
Correct you are
I’m not proud. I spend far too much time on Baseball-Reference.
I too spend too much time there.
I’m just happy I had guessed 3 of the 6 on the list (Trout/Griffey/Jones), not stat-specifically. Congrats!
The last few years of Hall of Fame balloting have resulted in me spending way too much time on Beltran, Dawson, Jones and Lofton’s B-R pages.
It’s funny because I never really considered Dawson a CF because he was in right by the time I started watching baseball. Dude had a cannon for an arm!
A reminder that 60 years ago is 1966, so it is anyone who had their first season in 1966 or later.
.
(o_O) ?
!
Look at the number of games played…. Mike Trout is still 34 and active, but there’s a good chance he won’t surpass anyone here in games played. Biggest “what if” for me in baseball for sure.
:(
Yeah.
Mike Trout has more seasons playing under 135 games than over 135 games in his career.
I never understood these “what if” narratives. It’s not like he was in a freak accident. The most important asset in baseball is staying healthy. So many greats - koufax, Griffey, Kirby puckett just to name a few - have gotten injured in the latter half of their careers. No one talks about their “what ifs”. What if bonds never took steroids? What if babe ruth drank from the grail of eternal youth? Health is one of the many factors that make players good. It’s not a footnote that is only relevant when it prevents a certain statistical output.
For the most part I agree. But JR Richard is a health what if that’s valid because his could’ve been caught and potentially fixed.
I’d add Koufax and Mantle to “What-if” too because in today’s game they could’ve been fixed. The “what if” being what if we had modern surgeries earlier to extend their career / athleticism
So what is the what if for trout? If he had bionic fingers that didn’t have tearable ligaments?
So…Griffey, Trout, Lofton, Jones, Beltran, and Dawson?
yes, but which one is which?
Just eyeballing but guessing Lofton is 1, Edmonds 2, Trout 3, Beltran 4, Griffey 5, Jones 6.
5⁄6 of those are correct
Lofton? Steals + I remember him having the .299 BA.
Either Dawson or Beltran. Can’t really distinguish between this one and number 4. I think Beltran ended up with more WAR than Dawson, so I’ll go the Hawk here and Beltran number four. Both 300-300 guys with 400+ homers.
Trout. Career not quite done yet.
Beltran
Griffey. 630 gives it away
Andruw! .254 BA + 400 home runs.
correct
The fact that Kenny Lofton was a one and done is an actual crime.
This is a put Lofton in HOF post.
Answer