[Thibodaux] Ballot #1 of the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame voting cycle is from Newsday’s Anthony Rieber. He selects three candidates and gives Buster Posey his first Hall of Fame vote. No adds or drops for returning candidates.
This year’s ballot is pretty mid ngl
Not many worthy candidates retired 5 years ago plus the ballot jam clearing up over the last 5-6 years has led to such a down ballot. Next year and the year after the 1st timers are much better.
It’s not mid, it’s bad. These guys all had very good MLB careers, but Posey and A-Rod are the only guys with surefire HoF credentials and there are plenty of off-field reasons not to vote for A-Rod. You can make a strong argument for a few others like Utley, but the overall ballot is weaker than what we’ve grown accustomed to.
Is Posey even surefire Hall of Fame credentials?
He has all of the hardware and will definitely make it, but his counting stats but are no where near surefire. They haven’t elected a guy with that few hits since Ralph Kiner 50 years ago.
Purely by stats no, he’s actually below the average HOF catcher.
But he has 3 rings, ROY, and an MVP. I’d say he has high odds.
I would say being the key to the core of three world series teams while being one of the best offensive players on all of them and guiding that pitching staff through each postseason is more than enough. Catcher is a weird position to vote on but I think his 2021 comeback season solidified his greatness.
Posey’ cWPA for the three championships- 2010: -4.1%- 2012: 0.7%- 2014: -9.5%
WPA for the three championships- 2010: -0.14%- 2012: 0.13%- 2014: -0.14%
Thurman Munson was also ROY, MVP, 7 time AS, same career WAR, only 2 World Series (they lost in ‘76), team captain, well-liked, and his career was cut short at 32 because he died. Not in the HoF.
Idk if that’s a knock on Posey. Thurman Munson should be in the Hall.
Posey’s rate stats are good, but his counting stats are disqualifying imo. If he played outfield he might not have even made the ballot with 1,500 hits, <175 HR, <800 RBI, <700 runs, <300 2B. His advanced HoF stats aren’t good either.
But he didn’t play outfield
Hypotheticals about what position he didn’t play aren’t a great argument because who knows how his stats would have improved playing a less demanding position. Also, I’m willing to die on the hill that it’s the Hall of Fame not the Hall of advanced stats.
Look great if he was a hitting pitcher though.
Yea but if he pitched and won 250 games with a 2.88 era and 2700 strikeouts he gets in. Also he gets in if he did all those numbers without hands or feet, imagine? What other hypotheticals we thinkin
“if he played the outfield” –well good thing that doesn’t matter. You can’t tell the story of baseball for a solid decade+ without including Buster Posey. Was the absolute leader of three WS winning teams. I’d rather have players in the Hall who had his level of impact for a more limited period of time than players who weren’t actually major stars but got lots of counting stats.
If my grandma had wheels she’d be a bicycle, silly hypothetical
So if he played a completely different position that he didn’t play and therefore had a completely differemt career to the one he did have them he would ha e had a different career? Got it
If he “will definitely make it”, does that, by definition, mean he’s a surefire candidate?
To me A-Rod is the best SS and 3B of all time. And I hated the man every year he played
“mid” might be putting it lightly. I genuinely think this is the weakest ballot since 2000.
Really? The 2000 ballot had two elected, eight who were elected later, and others who have created much debate around their candidacy.
It’s quite good. You have Posey and Buehrle.
This guy voted for three and you could only think of two and you think that’s a good ballot
Yes. Most ballots have two good choices. Like this one
I give Buehrle less than 50⁄50. He was good for a long time but never truly elite and played for forgettable teams other than 2005.
Hard to make into the HOF when you received Cy Young votes only 1 year out of 16
Buster Posey is now on track to be the first unanimous first-ballot HOF pick since Mariano Rivera.
Hold on, let me do the math. I may need to bust out Claude.
1 / 1 = 1 = 100%
Math checks out 👍
Shit, first AI helps solve Riemann, now this. Are we cooked?
r/TheyDidTheMath
r/theydidthemonstermath
r/itwasagraveyardmath
What does this mean grok?
Now that’s some solid extrapolation
I know some hate ballot season but i love it. Arguing over who is and isn’t a Hall of Famer is kinda fun.
Yep, this post brought a big grin to my face. Love ballot tracking season!
[Comment about how great/awful this ballot is]
Tis the season!
[reply either agreeing with your statement or arguing about how you’re an absolute sausage]
[Bloviating on our mutual superior baseball intelligence or telling you that you don’t know what you’re talking about learn ball]
feel like this is a single candidate year where you put a check mark on Posey and turn it in
I guess it’s a career over peak thing, but Pettite over Felix is absolutely wild to me.
Absolutely wild is a bit dramatic. I don’t think it has to be “career over peak”. If you take both into account then Pettitte still has a higher JAWS than Félix. I could understand old school writers voting for Pettitte with ~250 wins, ~2,500 K, and 5 rings.
Yeah, but Felix was pretty clearly one of the best pitchers in baseball for a significant part of his career. Andy Pettite wasn’t. He was always a good pitcher. At no point would he have been considered the one. Felix was.
Félix certainly had the better peak but it wasn’t great enough for long enough to give him a HOF case, at least in the eyes of an old school voter.
Okay, and Pettite never had any peak where he was one of the top 5 (maybe) pitchers in any year he pitched in. Hows that a HOFer?
Especially a writer from Newsday, Long Island’s paper of record.
Voting for Gardner is just blatant homerism.
Love the dude. But he belongs in Monument Park and not Cooperstown
He should get the nod for playing on historic Yankees teams. It’s hall of fame and the Mariners didn’t cut it.
Edit: It’s controversial but everything the hall does should be to suit the image of the sport. Those Yankees teams were among the greatest dynasties any sport has seen plus they gave the sport renewed visibility after the strike, especially given they were in the Big Apple. If you’re a “very good” player on the Yankees (or Dodgers) you shouldn’t face opposition from hall voters. Likewise if you’re borderline on a small market team you shouldn’t have a chance. It’s bad for the game. Posada? Hall of Fame. Bernie Williams? Hall of Fame. Joe Mauer? What the heck?!
All the good Yankee teams are historic tbf.
Pretty normal small hall ballot
I cant believe Kyle Seager and Ervin Santana retired at the same time
Man I remember when Castro debuted and was the first 90s baby to make it to the league
I think I had a baseball card for that! He had a couple nice years, led the league in hits once, I think. Can’t imagine him without that babyface.
And thus begins the onslaught of 200 posts where all the comments are people acting like their favorite “hall of very good” player not being included is an affront to humanity
“Voting for [insert player] but leaving off [insert another comparable player on the ballot that I happen to be a fan of] is ridiculous!!!”
All the comparisons of really good catchers not being in the hall for why posey shouldn’t be. Seen so many of them always.
I will die on the Mark Buehrle hill every time one of these posts comes up. I don’t care how much of a homer it makes me. That is my only opinion about any of these, stupid protest votes aside.
not his fault for playing in the steroid era. One of my favorite workhorses ever, but I’d expect a veteran’s committee induction before a BBWAA vote.
Yeah I don’t have high hopes for the BBWAA. He never really has an amazing peak (I think he only got Cy Young votes once) but dear lord he was super consistent over a very long time. Plus he faced the minimum 27 hitters 3 times (with one being a no-hitter and the other being a perfecto), and got a save on his way to win the world series while a few beers deep. Dude just has baseball aura.
Loved having him on my team growing up. One of my favorite baseball memories was going to the game where he and Sale went up against each other. Game was so fast I missed 3 innings getting a hot dog.
Haha, that sounds like a great game to have attended! I’m glad the White Sox did right and retired his number. He had a career worth remembering that’s for sure.
Okay but not including Chase Utley is an affront to humanity
”I agree Utley is an important part of telling the story of 2000’s baseball and deserves a spot in the hall. Excellent numbers for a career 2nd baseman” (If he gets in, Pedey’s chances go wayy up)
Incoming all the “catcher x isn’t in the hall so posey definitely shouldn’t be” comments
Id like to see what Catcher isnt in the HOF but has a MVP, ROTY, 7x All Star, 5 Silver Sluggers and was a key piece of 3 World Seriea Titles.
Thurman Munson is weirdly close to that: ROTY, MVP, 7x All-star, key piece of 2 World Series Titles, played before the silver slugger award, but did win 3 gold gloves.
(Both should be in the Hall)
Always found it strange he hasnt gotten in. I think he deserves it but I also would have thought be would have been voted in pretty close to his tragedy.
Yeah Munson is one of the people I’ve seen cited in this exact argument. The comparison also includes that they both had shorter than average careers and the hall puts a lot of weight on career length.
Munson is weird in that he was a Yankee that was actually underrated in hindsight and looks better under modern eyes. He would probably get in easily in today’s conditions.
I dont think many players with a ROY, MVP and multiple World Series aren’t in already.
And the catchers they name are worse players
Buster should be a shoo-in
I fully agree but I’ve just seen so many comments already. I’m hoping he’s first ballot but the amount of comments I’ve seen makes me think it will take a couple years
If he misses a first ballot indiction because of some “Gene Tenace” then the writers have lost the plot entirely.
Neither Pettitte nor Buehrle are HoF for me. But if you vote for 1, I feel you have to vote for the other. They’re so close in so many stats
Pettitte is getting votes because of his playoff numbers. That’s more or less the entire argument for him.
So because he was on a better team most of his career he should be in the HoF?
For me, having a perfect game and a no hitter is more impressive than pitching a lot of playoff games.
I think you can value Pettitte’s postseason enough to carve space between him and the other ~55-60 WAR pitchers. Career 52% WPA in the postseason.
sure they are close in some, but not all, stats. postseason performance matters a ton for the hall of fame and pettite threw 276 innings in the playoffs vs 30 for buehrle lol
buehrle was never a top pitcher. he received cy young votes in just one season
Pettitte has 16 more fWAR.
Both guys were rarely viewed as an ace. Pettitte was rarely even the best pitcher in his own rotation.
Both were absolute monsters of innings and longevity. Buehrle stared 30+ games every year when he was added to the rotation until he retired. Pettitte was equally impressive. He only had 3 seasons shortened by injury over 18 years.
Not HOF, but both should be in their Team’s HoF.
Pettitte was top 5 in Cy Young voting 5 times. Buehrle received Cy Young votes… once in his career.
Clearly they were viewed during their careers.
And that’s not even mentioning the post season difference. If Buehrle had 5 rings and a season and a half worth of postseason starts, his HoF candidacy would be much stronger.
Pettitte had 3 seasons with a WAR of 4 or more. Received CY votes in 2 seasons where his WAR was under 4.
Buehrle had 8 seasons with a WAR of 4 or more. The only year he received CY votes was his 5th best season by WAR.
The east coast bias answer is really simple
ALC vs ALE quality of their era
The answer is simple but it has nothing to do with east coast bias. The BBWAA hasn’t inducted a starting pitcher with under 2,000 K since 1976.
Posey is from the West Coast and he seems like a lock despite pretty awful counting stats.
He also gets a ton of credit for his rings. Why wouldn’t that count for Pettitte?
It begins
Pedroia at 0% it’s over
Bobby Abreu reached a base more often than both Tony Gwynn and Ichiro Suzuki. And did so in fewer plate appearances, while simultaneously both scoring more runs and driving in more runs. He is the only ballplayer in history, whose last name is not Bonds, to have at least 9x 20⁄20 seasons. He was never on the team I root for, so I don’t have a dog in this fight, but he should be in Cooperstown.
Here we go again
Happy Baseball HOF Ballot season.
I’m guessing the vote for Pettite instead of the other incredibly similar SP resumes is the championships.
Posey was a catcher who hit 30% better than average. He won a ROY and MVP. He was the best offensive player on 2 WS teams.
What a bad ballot. You can legit make a case only Buster deserves it.
Hall of very Goods
Goober ass ballot
How? He voted for the 3 best guys, honestly pettite probably isn’t a HOF but he’s at least close. No one else had a HOF career other than those 3
Because he didnt vote for Felix, any ballot that doesn’t include Gelix would be considered goofball to them
Utley is definitely good enough to be a hall of famer lol People here just don’t like him. He was one of the best players in the league for multiple years and had enough longevity to get over 60 fwar / bwar.
Yeah, he isnt very likeable.
Chase Utley (played for Phillies and Dodgers) did
Hamels and Pettite had basically the same career value except Hamels did it in like 700 fewer innings.
If Hamels pitched 700 more innings do you think his WAR would stay the same? Or would it maybe go down a bit?
I think it would go up. The disparity in IP is a result of the times in which they pitched and not because Hamels fell of a cliff or anything: he finished top 10 in IP three times as often as Pettitte did.
Mark Buehrle is deserving
Pettitte isn’t better than Utley
Joke of a ballot
If you have the option to select up to ten names, you should select ten. Could help the more borderline cases.
Why not only vote for guys who should be in?