[Murray] Sources: Giants open to trade offers for star pitcher Logan Webb
I’m personally enjoying it
FTG :)
On this matter, we are in agreement.
I would be open to offers so I could reject them.
It’s like how I ask my staff for suggestions. I get a small rush every time I say No.
Are we going to compete with the Rockies this season?
That’s what they did this season.
No, they’ll actually be much better than the giants.
They’re gonna be better😂😂😂
I love Logan, but they’ve already wasted his peak years. They need to do right by him and ship him to a contender. Their system is so young and promising, but realistically it will take multiple years for them to completely overhaul their pitching infrastructure and for the young guys to get to the bigs.
Realistically should’ve traded him at the deadline last year but still he has 2 years of control at 18m a year and is still an elite pitcher that will probably see some benefit being on a good team vs being on the Giants.
The haul they would get for Webb would be awesome would really solidify their farm as top 3 in the league.
Gimme
with what prospects bro
Hartshorn would be a great start. If the Giants like him, then there would be a way to make it work after that.
I also, hope that you guys get away with robbery against the Giants.
Logan Webb with Cubs defense would put up Maddux stats, it would be insane.
Jed get on the horn
I’m not sure we have the prospects for him unless we make Hartshorn available and I don’t think they do. Sure would nice if we had Rojas to trade but Jed gave him up for half a season of a pitcher that they didn’t even trust to start in the playoffs.
I remember seeing the Giants asked the Brewers for Luis Pena at the deadline this year and the Brewers rejected. So I guess that’s the level of prospect they’re looking for lol
Yup they’ll surely want a big headliner
I’d feel bad for giants fans but also, I want
I don’t get Giants fans who are so against it. Yes Webb is loved by all of us. He’s meant to play winning ball and a clubhouse leader. But the Giants are in full rebuild and with Webbs innings the last 5 years, he’s likely going to be on the tail end of his prime. Giants could get a nice haul for him.And I just want to see him pitch a playoff game we’re nowhere close to that
Trading Webb is the absolute best move the Giants could make right now. He would be in such huge demand. He’s got a cheap enough contract than any team looking to contend next year could take him on.
Yeah it would make a lot of sense to make that move as quickly as possible. Most fans will get it, obviously he will be missed
Yes but it would make me so so so sad to see him go :(
Because he’s a hometown native that we actually drafted and developed? He was born in Rocklin and he came up through our system. He’s 30 year during the 2027 season which means he’s got 4 seasons (when he’s 33) until you should expect notable decline.
He’s never been a power pitcher, he sits 92-93 on his four seamer and he primarily relies on his sinker (91-92) and his changeup (84-86) while having great mechanics where he’s not stressing out his arm or hips or anything.
So realistically, he’s a pitcher that should age well and he’s criminally underpaid, it’s not like he costs us much. He’s only 23M AAV which is less than fucking Sean Manaea’s bum ass and less than Berrios, Luzardo, or Castillo. And I don’t want to hear it about Luzardo’s one good year when Webb has averaged 4.5 WAR a year over the last five.
You can’t have a complete dogshit team devoid of talent and leaders when you’re rebuilding. The people we should be looking to move are Adames and Chapman. Adames is on his last year of his contract anyways and will probably be dealt at the deadline to a contender and Chapman is getting old and expensive as shit, the first sign of him batting well we need to get whatever we can. Devers we need to keep so the lineup isn’t shit but he’s the most likely to give us a haul especially if he’s hot going into the AS break so I’d be fine with him being traded if we get something huge.
Not trying to argue with the thrust of your overall point, but Adames isn’t in the last year of his contract…where on earth did you get that idea?
Webb has had a better career but Luzardo is far better than Webb right now. So you can scratch Luzardo from that list of names.
Yup he’s at the age where he needs to go and compete for rings. That’s not going to be in SF
Yeahhhhhh I think I would make whatever deal they want with exception being Hartshorn. Not moving him. Matt Shaw, Jaxon Wiggins to start. Maybe throw in a Brooks Capel or some of the guys from the 2026 draft like Sorrell and Myles Bailey.
Just go ahead and fleece us already. We’re already used to it😪
But to be honest with your young and athletic defense Webb is probably right back to being Cy Young caliber.
One thing not really mentioned is that Webb is on an insanely team friendly deal so he probably commands a return even more than what his numbers look like. Doubtful we actually deal him.
Sure, whatever man. Just rip the bandaid off and trade everyone with a pulse at this point. Eat enough money to send Chapman to the Yankees and Adames back to Milwaukee, I don’t even care anymore.
We are boned anyways. Webb or no Webb.
The only thing surprising to me is how many people are surprised by this. The Giants have a good farm but basically everybody is 2 years away, and Webb would probably get a great haul in this pitching market. Chapman and Adames will be geriatric by the time those prospects are ready, but no use sticking your head in the sand pending that makes them a win-now team.
Buster Posey celebrating his appearance on the Hall of Fame ballot by burning every ounce of goodwill that Giants fans have towards him.
Fascinating strategy!
He already did that this past season. I think if they’re going to be bad, might as well fully tank. They can actually get a good draft pick by being bad on purpose this time, and then the next POBO can rebuild
Yea it’s hard to see the Giants competing with the Dodgers or Padres the next few years so may as well tank.
If they do it right, they’ll be loaded with young talent right as those two teams windows start to close (tho the Dodgers being the Dodgers their window is probably never going to close)
I don’t think it’s a bad decision at all. There’s no reason to believe the Giants will be contending at all in next year or two, so you might as well get a HAUL for Webb. He is one of the most consistent SP in baseball over the last 5-6 years and his contract is dirt cheap for the value you get. They could legitimately get a young top 10-15 prospect for Webb plus God knows what else. Start prepping for the future. It would actually be one of the smarter moves the Giants have made in quite a while. We have been holding on to our fan favorites for far too long and it has gotten us nowhere.
That’s genuinely why I think he was hired as pobo. All the good will we had for him as a player acted as a buffer for a few years while the ownership group fucks off and spends money on real estate investments instead of the team.
The Derek JeterTM
hmm….Cubs. Defense is too lousy in other places.
The Giants are a confusing team. Bryce Eldridge has potential but it’s not a cohesive deep unit of a team.
I doubt we actually trade him, but it would take a string of injury luck and a very good offseason of pitching acquisition to fully compete this year. If you can get a couple of top 100 prospects for Webb you have to listen. Our farm system is the best it’s been in forever. Rearming to compete in a year or 2 is not the worst decision.
The future is bright though. Their lower minors are insanely stacked right now. It’s good they aren’t going all in on competing in the next 2 seasons. If even a handful of the young guys they have with huge potential hit they could have a very strong team for a long time
You guys tried Bryce as your closer yet?
You sure you don’t want to keep him?
It would be a huge bummer to see him go, but it makes sense. This team is 2-3 years away, and trading Webb can help accelerate that timeline. Just fucking sucks to be in this position in the first place. This org should feel ashamed of itself
There is zero reason to not at least listen to offers. The Giants will not be competitive before his contract is up. The farm is starting to look pretty good, keep building for the future instead of wasting a talented pitcher in a couple of lost seasons.
Well I really liked the last big ex-Giants started we got
Twins defense would turn him into a 4.00 ERA pitcher through no fault of his own
Giants defense already did that to him last year.
So realistically, what window of contention is Buster aiming for now? Devers, Adames, and Chapman are all on the wrong side of 30 and they refused to listen to offers on Webb at the deadline this past season. Are they going full rebuild now?
Devers is not in the same category as Chapman and Adames.
Devers is good, Adames and Chapman have been terrible contracts.
I don’t understand how you guys broke Wily. He was such a reliable middle of the order bat then just aged 10 years
Chase rate guys after 30 are just cooked
He’s a terrible fit for the ballpark, his power is to right-center and that’s where hits and homers go to die in SF.
I never liked the contract because he seemed like a guy who would not age well. He was better than I thought his first year but then became what I thought afterwards
Giants are probably aiming to contend in 2-4 years. Giants don’t need to trade guys away to shed payroll because they have a shit ton of money (of course, a salary cap could change this a lot). They’re probably only looking to trade to upgrade their farm and completely fine keeping these guys around if they don’t get an offer they like.
Plus, casual fans come to games for guys like Devers and JHL even if the team is doing bad, so it’s not like their contracts are completely horrible.
The whole We have Trout or back in my day Hunter and cheap tickets come to our games please.
Denying reality
Defying reality
Devers slander is unwarranted but they are trying to move Adames and Chapman
Someone else in this thread is saying Giants shopped Webb at deadline: https://www.reddit.com/r/baseball/s/8U3YroSF5M
Directly asking an org for their #1 prospect and refusing to entertain any other offers isn’t really ‘shopping Webb’ at the deadline
Webb is one of the best pitchers in the league and in his prime on a team-friendly contract. You don’t trade guys like him for cheap, even on a down year.
Never said the Giants should trade him for cheap, or that asking for Pena was wrong. Just surprised the Giants FO didn’t put him on the trading block at the deadline this year and see what packages all the desperate contenders would have put together.
Giants are in for another decade of depression
Nah, the farm system is juiced and they have money to play with. Just have to get through the bad contract storm and they’ll be fine
yeah but they can’t really offload off any of them, and iirc the giants farm isn’t stacked with pitching talent, mostly SSes
You trade those SS’s for pitching if needed. And one of Adames or Chapman could very well bounce back next year and suddenly they’re movable. Chapman more likely id guess.
Giants just aren’t as bleak as people seem to think. Will have to be smart with their moves going forward of course, but there is a path that’s reasonably possible.
It’s a similar thing to the Cardinals a year or 2 ago. Everybody was trashing the Cardinals and saying we were 5-7 years away from being good… now we have arguably the best farm system and baseball with 15 prospects that are unranked in our 30 that would be top 15 in several systems. The big league talent is legit. Just need a couple of moves and bam we’re serious players. All it took was a playing things out with what we had (trading assets already on the roster) and letting guys grow. Now the near future looks super bright.
The Giants can follow that same playbook. Only question is does Posey actually have the chops. I’m doubtful about his GM ability, but we’ll see.
This is the right move
Funny how writers keep saying this is and then posey goes “no we’re not trading Webb. But obviously we will answer the phone on anyone”
Now all the Cubs podcasts are gonna talk about this again, but will never happen
Logan Webb is Logan Webb, but the prospect could be anything. It could even be Logan Webb!
You could have Logan Webb or you could have the Player to Be Named Later
Yeah but Logan Webb won’t be “Logan Webb” in 3-4 years when we have a chance to compete again. Reset the clock and get younger and better.
I cant believe how bad Posey has been. Or maybe I can and I just wanted it to go better.
Webb I absolutely think on a playoff contender could give them two elite years. But Giants shouldn’t hold out for something impossible. It’s the perfect time to send him off. Raid someone’s closet.
You guys should take him
He would be an excellent fit on their staff. And the Mariners still have a loaded farm.
they just traded another SP
Watch Buster take Emerson Hancock and some prospects not named Anderson or Sloan.
No way I want to gut our farm, but it would be dumb for us not to call. Jerry prefers trades over free agents.
This is my year to see how he does. Didn’t have much, farm is much better, moved on from guys that just went going to happen. The line up looked great on paper, the arms not so much, but this whole past season was basically everything going to hell with a new manager. Which was a choice, but I’m glad we didn’t get Bud Black or some retread. While I’d hate to see him go, Webb would help with a loooong overdue rebuild. We’ve been “retooling” for near a decade and ‘21 painted a false picture.
Can we interest you in one Mark Vientos?
A guy like that at 18 a year is exactly who the Royals should be calling about, and exactly who they wont call about. Two years of control is a real window too, that isnt a rental.
Probably the only giants player I like
Steroid user