Apparently the MLB is funding pro-owner ads through google ads
They’ve been showing these ads for months, including all through the postseason on network television
Horrible political ads followed by pro owner ads lol
“Support your local billionaire”
We should all be so thankful that they trickle down their economics to us
Yeah, something warm is trickling down onto us, and it ain’t economics…
Are you mocking the pro owner ads or the political ads?
yes
¿Por qué no los dos?
Yeah I’ve been seeing these on Youtube for a while now. Especially bad are the ones that are presented as if its a regular dude talking like a random TikToker
I’ve also seen a lot of suspicious comments on this topic in favor of the owners. Who fucking knows.
Yeah would not be surprised if they are paying for comments
not just comments but posts and interviews with journalists and shit.
But it’s “content’
I guess I wouldn’t put it past the guys who surveil patrons in taxpayer funded stadiums with minority report style tech to also dabble in social engineering just to squeeze actual workers a teensy bit more.
They are so out of touch they don’t realize that public opinion is not with the “owner” class right now.
Yeah I pointed this out the other day and I received a flood of very samey pro-owner talking point replies. It’s real sus around here right now
As soon as reddit went public, people started predicting that covert pr campaigns were their best path to monetization.
I mean there were people doing that well before Reddit went public, lol.
I mean reddit selling it as an automated service.
Has really gone to shit since they started letting people hide their comments.
Agreed. I can understand NSFW-specific accounts having that ability to help prevent stalking, doxxing, obfuscate identity, etc. but every account getting that ability is only serving to protect bots and paid shills.
I remember r/startrek was massively astroturfed to stamp out any criticism of Star Trek: Discovery & Picard.
It’s not so much that it is sus as it is the core nature of fandom. Players come and go while owners usually live in the background. What the fans actually identify with is the team.
I have no problem stating that I support a linked cap. Because I do think it helps competitive balance. And I have seen it first hand with the NHL. I also think that at the owners proposals for what should count as revenue and what should count against the players’ share is bullshit. So yes the owners are also looking to increase profits. But the union could negotiate all that into something reasonable.
What I don’t care about are arguments telling me I need to side with the 1% because they are squabbling with the 0.1%. And when push comes to shove, neither does most anybody else. Neither side is on the fans’ side. And the fans know it. That’s why everyone just wants them to hurry up, have their fight, and bring back our teams.
How does the NHL have parity? Almost all the cup winners since 2010 won because they drafted a superstar in the top 10. Players barely reach free agency as well.
Plus on top of that fans are crying how teams with no state tax have a big competitive advantage.
There has yet to he an AFC Championship Game without either the Chiefs or the Patriots in something like the last 15 years.
What you’re describing is largely a feature of the salary cap - if you can’t simply buy up all the best players then the most reliable way to acquire them is to draft them yourself. Look at the Leafs right now, I’m sure they’d love nothing more than the ability to buy their way out of the mess they’re in currently but they can’t. Chicago’s had multiple top picks and they still suck. Detroit hasn’t made the playoffs in a decade. Meanwhile, Minnesota and Carolina (the reigning Cup champs) are the top-2 teams in the league currently. San Jose is gonna be a wagon within the next couple years.
Yeah the idea that anyone who supports a cap/floor deal is a shill is just insulting. All else equal sure I’d rather the players get paid than the owners but I’m first and foremost a fan, I just want to 1. watch baseball and 2. see my team win. I’m sure the deal the owners are offering is not nearly as good as they’re making it sound but the players’ position of just flat out refusing to negotiate on any deal that includes a cap is ridiculous.
Like the players’/reddit’s position seems to be that the owners should just unilaterally all decide to spend more money? I mean sure that would be nice but unless we’re talking about appropriating the teams under public ownership (which btw I would absolutely support) something does actually need to get given up in exchange
I’m sure the deal the owners are offering is not nearly as good as they’re making it sound but the players’ position of just flat out refusing to negotiate on any deal that includes a cap is ridiculous.
what do you mean? Players have already agreed to luxury tax which deters spending. So they’ve budged in the past.
”… but the players’ position of just flat out refusing to negotiate on any deal that includes a cap is ridiculous.”
You do realize that the owners are the ones insisting on the cap? And that they are the ones who will institute a lockout if they don’t get it.
Calling you guys “shills” is being polite, because it would at least explain why you all just thoughtlessly parrot the same exact half-baked arguments word for word in every thread, and then run away as soon as someone pushes back.
The alternative explanation — that you all independently came to the same conclusion, but are all completely incapable of substantively defending your position — is way more embarrassing.
What I don’t care about are arguments telling me I need to side with the 1% because they are squabbling with the 0.1%.
To me it’s the principle.
Why should anyone say, “You can’t make more money for your hard work. We know people want to pay you more, but we won’t let them!”
Plain and simple. That’s communist and un-American.
If MLB were dying and teams were contracting because low payroll teams can no longer make money, it’d be one thing. Then you’d need a cap otherwise the sport will die.
No competitive issue.
The other thing that market size and success isn’t true. MARKET SIZE has no effect on baseball success:
If, instead of payroll, the analysis uses “market score” — a metric that factors in TV audiences, population and median household income — then market size explains almost nothing statistically about how a team will fare. The same holds true when looking at whether Nielsen’s rankings of audience sizes affect regular-season success.
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7716072/2026/10/23/mlb-salary-cap-competitive-balance-analysis/
So, since market size has no impact, then players should be allowed to make as much money as they can.
People have different opinions, there are clear reasons why redditors would be for example wanting a cap/floor
There is nothing weird about people having opinions like that. Would be more weird if everyone was pro player union
Turns out a lot of people want a salary cap. There isn’t anything suspicious about that
You made a statement about something and the people you were talking about responded a bunch? Yeah, totally sus.
This 100% has happened in r/KCRoyals and r/KansasCityChiefs whenever there was posts about building new stadiums
Suspicious how?
They don’t agree with his/her point of view lol. I’m sure there’s some astroturfing from both sides to be fair but the pro player side increasingly calls people bots for not agreeing with them.
It should be expected. The world is never a monolith on any subject. It would only make sense sometimes people are pro-owner in some respects.
I can’t think of anything off the top of my head that I agree with the owners on right away, but that also doesn’t mean I agree with EVERYTHING the players want
I’m sure there’s some astroturfing from both sides
You think Francisco Lindor, Marcus Semien, Jack Flaherty, and Lance McCullers Jr. pay people to post anti-owner reddit comments….?
Lotta people saying, “The cap is actually pro player, it will get them lots of money except for the SUPER EVIL GREEDY PLAYERS UNION REPS!”
I think it’s insane to think everyone who’s not on the players side is a bot or shill.
I’m comfortable saying 95% of posters on this sub don’t remember 94 and how bad it was for the game and how much people hated the players. Why is it so bad to say that I don’t care who wins as long as we have baseball?
Sure I want the players to win in abstract. But given a choice between that taking possibly half to whole season, or the owners winning getting a cap, and oh no millionaires are still rich and billionaires are still richer? Easy choice.
Yes we’re closer to the players than they are the billionaires. But at the end of the day, the players get our lifetime earnings by the time they turn 30. I’m not shedding tears for them. I just don’t care about either side. Doesn’t make me “suspicious”
Just because someone disagrees with you doesn’t mean there is anything suspicious going on.
What is suspicious about baseball fans wanting a salary cap?
No fan should want to hand greedy owners another chance to take a bigger slice of the pie from the players who actually entertain us.
They already line their own pockets on the backs of our fandom every chance they get
You can feel however you want, but accusing everyone with a different opinion of being a bot or shill is just intellectually lazy and the exact type of nonsense that is getting upvoted in this thread
ok bot
No normal fans care at all about owners.
Well apparently we’re bots, paid shills, or just billionaire bootlickers according to the labor activist cosplayers on this sub.
I mean, when there are polls saying that 70 percent of fans support a cap/floor it is perfectly reasonable to believe that there are bots or other non-organic actors trying to flood the sub. Just not in favor of a cap/floor.
The arguments are suspicious. I’m cap ambivalent - if there was a genuine proposal for a fixed revenue share that favors players, with a high floor, it would be hard to say that’s anti-player. That proposal doesn’t exist.
Ambivalent because I also don’t think caps make for better entertainment - the NFL and NBA still have dynasties but what they also have is constant roster churn, with cuts and trades made not to build the best possible roster but to save money. Baseball has had plenty of winners and losers over the last 20 years without a cap and anyone harboring a fantasy that it will save their team should have watched all the times the Dallas Mavericks tried to sign a marquee free agent when Miami and LA existed.
Pro-cappers, though, parrot suspiciously owner-compliant arguments. Pretending that it will benefit the majority of players and akshually it’s just the elite who are against it. (This is completely untrue - given a smaller share of actual revenue and a cap, more salary will go to stars. Replacement level players are just that.) They don’t acknowledge the difference in MLB’s floor and cap numbers compared to the NBA or NFL. They don’t acknowledge how much it would hurt incoming players to cut draft bonus pools and institute an international draft.
I’m sure I’ll get downvoted to hell, but why is someone on the side of a salary cap suspicious? Why isn’t someone on the side of the players suspicious.
I want a cap and floor, and could not care less how high they are as long as they’re close to each other. I just want all teams on the same level.
I truly don’t want to favor the owners, despite believing that a cap/floor is definitely the only way to move forward.
But I’m sure their expectation of what that cap and floor should be would be way out of line with reality.
Remember kiddies, class war is the only war worth fighting.
I really wish this sub would understand that being in favor of a cap and floor doesn’t make you in favor of the owners and it’s a popular opinion in the real world. But I guess nah those are clearly bot comments. And absolutely nothing suspicious about the constant comments that are pretending this is a fight between the working class and the mustache twirling bourgeoisie instead of a fight between the very rich and the extremely rich.
remind us all again which side here works for their living? now stop both-sidesing this. one side is bad, yes.
They’ll spend an arm and a leg on bots, but they won’t pay their employees?
Yes, because bots are a one-time expense that returns long-term or even permanent benefits/savings.
Wdym don’t pay their employees? Not disagreeing just not sure what you’re referencing
Which employees? Isn’t the minimum salary 780,000?
Ton of people pushing the idea that, “A cap will actually give the players more money.”
I asked, “Well then why are the owners pushing it so hard,”
Got no good answers, just mass downvoted.
Wont someone please think of the billionaires!
A lot of the people here against the salary cap don’t actually listen to the arguments made in favor of it. They just shout “you’re pro-owner! Go lick billionaire boots!”
I support a salary cap because I believe it’s better for the sport of baseball. The other big sports leagues have a salary cap. And a salary floor, which is basically guaranteed to happen if a cap passes, will let the players have a direct say in how much the owners spend on payroll. As opposed to now, where if a cheap owner wants to spend a tiny amount on salaries, there’s no recourse.
People will have different opinions than you. It doesn’t mean they’re bots or paid off.
And seen a lot of suspicious comments against the cap. Profiles with history blocked or suspiciously new accounts.
A salary cap won’t make nutting any less shit. It will just make him more guaranteed profits.
It won’t make cherrington any less shit and will only allow nutting to blame him for his sweet sweet profits while they continue to suck. And have to overpay for mid players so they can continue to suck
Nor will it stop skenes from wanting to leave for a competent franchise
The only thing a salary cap does is put more money into billionaires hands. Billionaires who just got rewarded by showing that going 2 decades without a playoff series win and being 2nd fiddle in their town for 4 billion dollars.
Think for a second. If a salary cap created “competitive balance” why would the owners want to make their job harder?
Cap and floor. And a cap does actually mitigate a lot of that, as the Dodgers and Mets can’t throw half a billion at players and then sign other guys too. Yes, some star players will lose out on earnings, but lower and mid-level guys will see increases, even if it is just bad teams throwing money at them to hit the floor. The thing is, I’m not upset if players get screwed over, because they are a bunch of scabs. They are the second most anti-labor union in the country, behind police unions. Never show support for stadium workers. And before you say the owners are the same, I agree they are, with the caveat of not being hypocrites. And if the owners want great PR, say they will cover any lost wages for any games missed for stadium workers. Because I doubt the players will even think about guys in the minors on the 40-man who can’t play.
Yep. They are a bunch of republicans who are anti union.
why would bob nutting drop 100m in financial loss every year, because let’s face it doubling his spending isn’t doubling his income, just to try to compete with the mets and the dodgers?
It’s crazy the anti cap people talk about how greedy they are, but then are against fixing that problem
Come on man your profile is closed.
Apparently Reddit is auto doing that, since yours is too.
Like yours 🤣
Wasn’t last time I checked, and isn’t anymore.
There’s also been an influx of anti-cap content on reddit. Some posted by accounts that are new, some awokened. Some that I can see a history of never posting about baseball, some that suspiciously have their post history hidden, including some that posted so much I could recognize their username as being clearly shill accounts for the MLBPA.
Both sides have hundreds of millions, if not billions, at stake here. Neither side is trying to be a moral, greater-good saint, both just want more money for themselves.
Yes, it’s a labor dispute. That’s what labor disputes are for: negotiating money and rights. I don’t know what fans think they’re arguing when bringing this up. The owners are locking out the players because they want more money, and they will harm baseball in whatever way they can to do so.
…because the implication of bringing it up is that the players are pure and ethical beings worthy of support on moral grounds, and not simply interested in advancing their interests and nothing else like the owners are.
The lockout happening is purely the mlbpas fault. We used to just let them play while they figured it out, but the MLBPA fucked the fans
Nobody should be pro-either side. Do you like paying \(80 a ticket so your favorite player can make \)30 million/year instead of scraping by on $15 million?
I imagine I’d be paying $80 a ticket either way. It’s not like a salary cap has made the NFL or NBA cheaper.
You don’t think the owners will maximize income regardless of contracts?
Have you heard your own owner speak??
Yes, the people making the entertainment should make as much as possible. That argument makes no sense. Players making $30 million are 33 times closer to bankruptcy than they are to the billionaires who own the teams.
There is no pro-owner argument that makes any lick of practical sense from a fan’s perspective.
I mean a cap and floor immediately benefits the large majority of fans by taking the extreme financial advantages from large markets
Oh sure let’s spare a thought for the poor players that only make more in a year than Americans will make in 5 lifetimes.
If a cap and floor is pro owner then so be it. But I also know people on this sub love to pretend that cap and floor supporters are billionaire bootlickers because that’s the only way you guys know how to shut down arguments.
Nah, I watch baseball to see the players. The owners can collectively eat a bag of dicks.
Who pays the players to be on your team
I watch to see the players on my specific team.
I like Julio because he’s on the Mariners, I wouldn’t care about him if he played for the Twins.
So it’s not as simple, at least for me, as saying I watch to see the players. I watch to see my team.
So how many times have you rooted for your team to lose?
you watch baseball to see the 20 guys who are paid decently? guess the entire rest of the league can go fuck themselves in your eyes?
NHL has the strictest cap and yet you can’t get into MSG for less than $100.
MSG is a shitty example, even when the knicks or rangers are ass the tickets sell cause of its damn location, the only time I’ve been in MSG is for free cause of tickets from work. You want cheap hockey go to a Devils or Islanders game, I’m taking my nephew to an islanders game right before thanksgiving for $40 a ticket
The point is a cap doesn’t equal cheaper tickets. The cap was flat for 5 years yet ticket prices still went up.
While true there are half as many games, and half as much capacity. Basically a quarter as many tickets are available over the entire season.
I get your point but there also is a much smaller audience for NHL than MLB. $100 for nosebleeds isn’t cheap at all and it’s not the price because of a cap but because Dolan knows he can get away with it. For a league that had a stagnant cap for 5 year. The ticket prices definitely didn’t stagnate.
I think Hal Steinbrenner is a pretty swell and upstanding owner
It’s a crime you’re being downvoted for this outstanding comment
Jesus wept
I don’t know why you find this surprising. MLB the organization (including the commissioner) is not a neutral party. It is owned by and works at the behest of the team owners.
Lol this post has hundreds of upvotes too, so its not just him apparently
MLB is the owners. You’re basically saying the owners are funding pro-owner ads.
Fuck the billionaires.
Salary cap proposal is NOT about competitive balance. It’s about ownership profits. Don’t be fooled by this propaganda.
Support the workers, not the owners!
When the workers make more money than almost every “evil greedy CEO” I’m supposed to hate it makes things weird
Citation needed.
Just take on bad contracts to get to the salary floor. No real spending that means anything
We don’t care if it helps ownership make more profit if it helps to balance the playing field. Its not the fans concern who is making the money, our concern is the product on the field
How would you feel if you got salary capped at your job??
Dude they’re making Millions, these comparisons don’t work
And the owners are billionaires. And besides any of that it’s not your money.
Players earn millions through their work.
Owners use their billions to make more billions off of the backs of other people’s work, and by underpaying the people performing that work.
Not relevant. I’m a fan of the mlb product, I am not an mlb player.
L + ratio + unflaired + who’s we? + no bitches
There are dozens of better ways to address competitive balance than a salary cap.
Salary cap has not been effective at creating competitive balance in the NFL.
That is incorrect
This is a delusional take. Salary cap has been extremely effective at creating competitive balance in the NFL. The Chiefs are among the lowest revenue earners in the league each year but have had incredible success over the last decade. If there were no salary cap, the cowboys - who earn nearly double the next highest revenue team in the league - would become the dodgers, signing every all-pro at every position for insane contracts. Any team can compete if they draft well and make good decisions about who to keep and who to sign or trade for.
Or you could just invoke Mariners vs. Seahawks for brevity’s sake.
There is frequent and enormous turnover in team quality in the NFL. Let me guess, another person who’s gonna parrot “bUt KaNsAs CiTy???” like you’re not proving the very point showing off a small market that’s been highly successful in the NFL.
Football is also not a perfect 1-to-1 comparison because no position in baseball has as much impact as a star quarterback does in football and drafting one of those gives you a huge advantage. Emphasis on drafting, which is how almost every team acquires one of those QBs, not by out-spending every other team by 500%.
Wut holy fuck this is some flat earth shit
Sure, just fall for the MLBPA propaganda instead
A salary cap (and floor) also helps competitive balance. Trust me, these players will still get paid and they’ll still make more than you and me.
They should be making money that’s proportional to the money they generate. Owners are making a massive amount of money, and players are the only reason owners make that money. Owners just want to have more leverage and a system that tips the scale completely on their favor.
So like the a set percentage of the revenue generated by the teams maybe
But the owners do not want to be transparent about the books.
Owners are making a massive amount of money
No, they aren’t. Juan Soto made more in 2025 than any team had in EBITDA.
If the owners weren’t making massive amounts of money they wouldn’t be in the fucking business.
If the team is willing to give him that money, they know they are gonna get that money back and then some.
There’s no cap on what the owners make. Why should the players have a cap on what they make?
Revenue sharing would cap what the owners make and they already proposed a 50-50 split. That split would likely go up once negotiations actually start
Cap them too, got for it.
Cap is tied to a percentage of revenue, which means it would also effectively be a cap on what the owners make.
Its kind of hilarious when someone spouting a position that is not supported by the vast majority of fans has over 150 “totally organic” upvotes.
You might be surprised to learn many fans actually support players, support unions, and oppose the idea of billionaires trying to buy public opinion.
Sounds like a super organic comment, of the ignoratio elenchi variety! Many fans also support puppies!
I don’t exactly know how to convince you that I’m a real person if 6 years of reddit history and ~20,000 contributions doesn’t do it.
Not everyone will you agree with you (or me) on the internet. That’s ok.
But let’s be clear - the astroturfing is coming from the billionaires who are buying TV time. Not from fans like me who might have a different opinion.
Fuck the millionaires too
Both of this year’s Cy Yound Award winners earned less than $1M
MLB has a three-pronged attack for their ads. Subliminal, liminal, and superliminal
Also sublingual
What’s Gaylord Perry got to do with this?
Sublime entering the conversation
Yvan Eht Nioj
HEY YOU! GO JOIN THE NAVY!!
Did you watch baseball at all this year? How is this a surprise?
You’re telling me that a bunch of billionaires are spending money to advance their own financial interests?
This is unprecedented evil.
Here in CA they played ads for months to strike down the billionaire tax and fooled enough people into voting against it. They probably paid more than what they’d have to pay in taxes on ads alone.
to the public who have no say its not even like selling yachts to those on skid row cause some day they might strike it rich we the fans will never be players or owners so we will never be at the negotiating table.
Owners own the league what do you expect
Everyone should stop using Google and add a blocker extension to their browser.
Why wouldn’t MLB fund ads supporting its position? Rob Manfred and the league are just a mouth piece for the owners.
The fans are not at the negotiating table. We have no say. Neither side will listen to us either.
If you don’t think a public in favor of ownership plays better for the owners than a public in favor of the players then I don’t know what to tell you.
Of course fans have a say. The sport (as a moneymaking venture) doesn’t exist without eyeballs on it.
Customers who pay for literally everything are powerless.
TIL
I’m still just confused why the PR battle is so important to them. Even if we as fans do take their side, how does it even help them?
I think it’s less about owners winning over fans and more about making the players out to be the ‘bad guys’.
Point the finger, demonize your opposition and spend millions in propaganda to protect your billions, at all cost. Same tactic has been used in union busting since the onset of organized labor.
Public opinion. Changing one member of the public’s mind doesn’t matter, but millions of people matter. If you can use propaganda to sway people from not caring or “the owners are greedy” to “the players are greedy” or “they’re both greedy” then the propaganda worked. Social media, regular media, it’s all affected by public opinion.
It’s just regular politics but there’s no election. The equivalent of the apathetic or low-info voter is who these ads are for.
Ive seen a bunch of these ads on YouTube so it’s definitely true
What even is the point of this?
I DGAF about either group….
I can’t imagine seeing an ad for either that makes an impression on me.
🤷🏼♂️
I don’t care if I’m on the same side as the owners, a salary cap and floor will be better for the competitive landscape of professional baseball.
Also it’s such a reach to turn this into some sort of labor stance. They’re baseball players not coal miners.
It’s a bigger reach comparing professional baseball players to coal miners.
You guys really need to start changing up the script, this copy+pasting is starting to get a little too on-the-nose
these have been going on for months now…but yes, agreed, it’s pathetic and cringe-inducing
The owners feel like the politician that tries way too hard to be relatable and fails miserably
Does anyone recognize these influencers? Are they real or are these all actors?
Of course they are. They’re not called the “parasite class” for nothing.
lol how? the owners have no money, remember? lol
What is the purpose of all this propaganda targeted at fans? None of us have a say in any part of this negotiation. Almost none of us care about the owners at all. The only reason why some of us are somewhat open to a salary cap is because we want more teams to have a chance, not because we give a shit about the owners. But again, we have no influence over negotiations, so what’s the point of all this?
It’s so weird this campaign. Like it’s not up to us
They also are advertising on TikTok. @Level_The_PlayingField is the account paying for ads, though they put the free ones on @mlb
Kind of a side note but sort of related. I rewatched Margin Call this morning, and that movie is a pretty solemn and smart take on the financial crisis and the types of people involved. I always recommend it as a follow up to The Big Short for people who are interested.
Well I finished Margin Call and Prime recommend a movie called The Last Days of Lehman Brothers.
It was like Temu Big Short. There is a scene early that shows Hank Paulson meeting with the big banks to convince them to bail out Lehman, and it dared to paint them in a good light. At that scene I was convinced the movie was financed by the big banks to make them look like they actually sacrificed to save the economy, and I turned that shit off.
The manipulation of public perception of the centers of power is quite frankly the most important thing to pay attention to in all of civilization.
Sports franchises and the now open relationships with gambling are toxic as fuck.
I like watching athletes do cool shit, but as people we really need to start checking ourselves.
Getting way too Roman around here.
Time for the nuclear option; push to strip MLB of its exemption from anti-trust laws.
The owners wanna propagandize us, OK, the players union should fight back.
At the very least it will renew interest in anti-trust laws. This could lead to breaking up some of the obvious monopolies in this country.